Should Pit Bulls Be Banned? - Spokane, North Idaho News & Weather KHQ.com

Should Pit Bulls Be Banned?

HUFFINGTONPOST.COM - Should pit bulls be banned in Texas? The question has sparked an enormous debate that ultimately brings us to the age old question of "nature vs. nurture." Are pit bulls inherently dangerous, or are their owners responsible for making them aggressive?

Justin Clinton, a 10-year-old boy from Texas, was mauled to death in 2009 by two pit bulls. After winning a $7 million civil suit against the dog's owners, the Clintons are now proposing "Justin's Law." The legislation written by Cynthia Kent, the family's attorney, would make it a third-degree felony to own a pit bull in Texas, though it currently has no sponsors in the Legislature.

Despite the proposed law having a slim chance of passing, it has ignited a heated debate over the animal breed. Pit bull owners are outraged, as seen in the HLN footage below of the Shoemaker family. They have good reason to be upset - their pit bull saved them from an intruder who shot the dog three times before running away. The pit bull was awarded the "Dog of Valor" award.

Dog trainer Michele Crouse believes that it's not the dog's breed, but rather the dog's owner who determines the animal's aggression. "It's all upon the responsibility of the owner and not what dog they have," she told NBC. "It doesn't matter if they have a 2-pound Chihuahua or a 200-pound mastiff."

The Dallas Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals accepts pit bulls at its shelters. As SPCA of Texas president James Bias explains, "We treat every dog coming in here as an individual rather than lumping them in as a specific breed type."

The American Temperament Test Society evaluates dog instincts. In the past, pit bulls have reportedly ranked better than average - the American Pit Bull Terriers recently scored an 85.3%, ranking above the much-beloved Golden Retriever.

But advocates of the ban suggest that dog bite statistics speak louder than temperament tests. According to a study conducted by Merritt Clifton, editor of "Animal People," pit bulls are responsible for a higher percentage of dog bites than most other dogs.

Clifton argues that the humane community doesn't encourage pumas for cat adoption, because "it is clearly understood that accidents with a puma are frequently fatal. For the same reason, it is sheer foolishness to encourage people to regard pit bull terriers... as just dogs like any other, no matter how much they may behave like other dogs under ordinary circumstances."

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • UPDATE: Motorcycle passenger killed in Rathdrum crash identified

    UPDATE: Motorcycle passenger killed in Rathdrum crash identified

    Monday, June 18 2018 1:53 PM EDT2018-06-18 17:53:47 GMT

    RATHDRUM, Idaho - Members of the Kootenai County Sheriff's Office and the Northern Lakes Fire Department responded to a fatal crash in Rathdrum late Saturday morning. A citizen reported that a truck struck a motorcycle carrying two people in the intersection at W. Lancaster Rd. and N. Huetter Rd. 

    >>

    RATHDRUM, Idaho - Members of the Kootenai County Sheriff's Office and the Northern Lakes Fire Department responded to a fatal crash in Rathdrum late Saturday morning. A citizen reported that a truck struck a motorcycle carrying two people in the intersection at W. Lancaster Rd. and N. Huetter Rd. 

    >>
  • Tests confirm mystery animal shot in Montana was a wolf

    Tests confirm mystery animal shot in Montana was a wolf

    Monday, June 18 2018 12:37 PM EDT2018-06-18 16:37:05 GMT
    Image Courtesy KXLO via KFBBImage Courtesy KXLO via KFBB

    HELENA, Mont. - The mystery is over: Montana wildlife officials confirm that an unusual-looking animal shot in central Montana was actually a wolf.    Montana Fish, Wildlife and Parks officials initially weren't certain what the creature was when a rancher shot it near Denton in May. They noted the legs, front claws and canine teeth were shorter and its ears bigger than normally seen on wolves. 

    >>

    HELENA, Mont. - The mystery is over: Montana wildlife officials confirm that an unusual-looking animal shot in central Montana was actually a wolf.    Montana Fish, Wildlife and Parks officials initially weren't certain what the creature was when a rancher shot it near Denton in May. They noted the legs, front claws and canine teeth were shorter and its ears bigger than normally seen on wolves. 

    >>
  • Victim in domestic violence situation turned house fire speaks out

    Victim in domestic violence situation turned house fire speaks out

    Monday, June 18 2018 6:43 PM EDT2018-06-18 22:43:22 GMT

    SPOKANE, Wash. - It's been a tough 24 hours for the Winant Family.  Kelli Winant says she called police after a situation escalated with she and her boyfriend Saturday after he had been drinking.  "After he beat me pretty good yesterday, he burned our house down,” Kelli Winant Firefighters were at the home in a matter of minutes.

    >>

    SPOKANE, Wash. - It's been a tough 24 hours for the Winant Family.  Kelli Winant says she called police after a situation escalated with she and her boyfriend Saturday after he had been drinking.  "After he beat me pretty good yesterday, he burned our house down,” Kelli Winant Firefighters were at the home in a matter of minutes.

    >>
HD DOPPLER 6i
/