Three out of four child booster seats fail safety test - Spokane, North Idaho News & Weather KHQ.com

Three out of four child booster seats fail safety test

WASHINGTON. - Tuesday, a group of highway safety experts released their take on the best child booster seats available and several manufacturers ended up with seats on both the 'recommended' and 'not recommended' lists.

Studies show children, ages 4 to 8, are 45 percent less likely to suffer serious injury in accidents if they're in a booster seat and if that booster is properly belted.

Experts say seat belts that cross a child's stomach can cause abdominal injury and belts that cross the neck or too low on the chest can lead to head and spine injuries and that's what the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety focused on for its latest ratings on booster seats.

'Best' list:

  • Combi Dakota backless/clip
  • Recaro Young sport 
  • Recaro vivo 
  • Maxi-cosi rodi xr 
  • Evenflo big kid amp backless/clip 
  • Eddie Bauer auto booster 
  • Cosco juvenile pronto 
  • Britax frontier 
  • Clek oobr


'Good Bets' list:

  • combi kobuk backless/clip
  • maxi-cosi rodi 
  • evenflo symphony 65 
  • britax parkway sg 
  • graco turbobooster safeseat wander 
  • graco turbobooster safeseat sachi

'Not Recommended' list:

  • harmony secure comfort deluxe backless/clip
  • combi kobuk 
  • evenflo express 
  • eddie bauer deluxe 
  • safety 1st alpha omega elite 
  • evenflo sightseer 
  • alpha omega elite 
  • eddie bauer deluxe 3-in-1 
  • safety 1st all-in-one 
  • alpha omega luxe echelon 
  • alpha omega

"Parents should avoid buying the 11 boosters on our "not recommended" list. These seats do not provide good belt fit," said Anne McCartt of The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety.

Seven of the eleven on the list come from one manufacturer, Dorel Juvenile Group, that offers the Eddie Bauer, Safety 1st and Alpha Omega brands.

Dorel pointed out that several of its seats made the 'best' or 'good bets' lists and says all of its seats meet or exceed government regulations.

Evenflo said the same thing when contacted. It, too, had seats that tested well but two fell under 'not recommended' and Evenflo says all of its child restraint seats undergo rigorous testing.

Harmony strongly defended its secure comfort deluxe and questioned the institute's testing procedures.

The makers of the Combi Kobuk are curious because they say its seat has passed previous institute testing.

Most safety experts say poorer performing seats still protect children in crashes.

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Police impersonator attempts to pull over Spokane woman

    Police impersonator attempts to pull over Spokane woman

    Monday, September 17 2018 8:45 PM EDT2018-09-18 00:45:37 GMT

    SPOKANE, Wash. - "He told me to pull over, and my jaw just dropped," a Spokane woman, who says a fake police officer tried to pull her over, doesn't want to be named. In fear, this could happen again. "It really scared me and kind of threw me off that night. I don't even want to drive by myself anymore," she said. She tells me that she was driving around North Spokane at night on her way home from work. 

    >>

    SPOKANE, Wash. - "He told me to pull over, and my jaw just dropped," a Spokane woman, who says a fake police officer tried to pull her over, doesn't want to be named. In fear, this could happen again. "It really scared me and kind of threw me off that night. I don't even want to drive by myself anymore," she said. She tells me that she was driving around North Spokane at night on her way home from work. 

    >>
  • Report: Olympia woman refuses to pull over for WSP trooper because she drives a Prius

    Report: Olympia woman refuses to pull over for WSP trooper because she drives a Prius

    Monday, September 17 2018 1:45 PM EDT2018-09-17 17:45:44 GMT

    MARYSVILLE, Wash. - An Olympia woman wouldn't pull over for a Washington State Patrol trooper because she drives a Prius, according to an arrest report.

    >>

    MARYSVILLE, Wash. - An Olympia woman wouldn't pull over for a Washington State Patrol trooper because she drives a Prius, according to an arrest report.

    >>
  • Police: Man killed by Cheney officers planned death

    Police: Man killed by Cheney officers planned death

    Tuesday, September 18 2018 1:27 AM EDT2018-09-18 05:27:11 GMT

    SPOKANE, Wash. (AP) - Court documents indicate that a man who was killed by Cheney police officers earlier this month had reported himself to police the evening of the shooting. The Spokesman-Review reports 40-year-old Steve Anderson was shot by three officers in a grocery store parking lot after police say he was wielding a knife and moved toward officers. 

    >>

    SPOKANE, Wash. (AP) - Court documents indicate that a man who was killed by Cheney police officers earlier this month had reported himself to police the evening of the shooting. The Spokesman-Review reports 40-year-old Steve Anderson was shot by three officers in a grocery store parking lot after police say he was wielding a knife and moved toward officers. 

    >>
HD DOPPLER 6i
/