Why Is It Hard To Prosecute A Cop? - Spokane, North Idaho News & Weather KHQ.com

Why Is It Hard To Prosecute A Cop?

SEATTLETIMES.COM - Washington's 25-year-old law regulating the use of deadly force by police provides a much broader defense than most other states' laws, a key reason that officers are rarely prosecuted in this state.

The law lays out a four-part test for determining whether use of deadly force is justifiable homicide. The officer must reasonably believe the suspect is attempting to commit a felony; has probable cause to believe his life is in danger, or that or others' lives are; and that the force is "necessary."

But the fourth provision sets an even higher bar: The officer is justified if he is acting "without malice" and in "good faith." Malice is defined in some cases as an "evil intent" or an "abandoned and malignant heart."

"Most states don't have a specific standard like that," said David Harris, a University of Pittsburgh law professor who studies the use of force. Instead, states more often give prosecutors broader discretion in determining whether to charge officers, he said.

Malice is extremely hard to prove, especially against police officers, who jurors are predisposed to believe are the "good guys," said Harris. "Putting a police officer on trial effectively turns the world upside down for the average person."

On Wednesday, King County Prosecutor Dan Satterberg cited the "malice" provision in his nine-page analysis as a reason for not charging Seattle police Officer Ian Birk with killing First Nations woodcarver John T. Williams.

Birk didn't know Williams and had no known animus against Native Americans, the homeless or the mentally ill, according to the analysis.

At a news conference, Satterberg said "a jury could not possibly find unanimously and beyond a reasonable doubt that Officer Birk acted with malice or bad intent."

Seattle attorney Tim Ford, who represents Williams' family, disputed Satterberg's analysis, citing evidence that Birk instigated the deadly confrontation with Williams.

"The question is, why couldn't a jury find malice?" Ford asked at an afternoon news conference.

Washington's justifiable-homicide law was passed in 1986 in the wake of a U.S. Supreme Court case, Tennessee v. Garner, which limited police officers' authority to shoot fleeing suspects. At the time, Washington's law allowed deadly force simply if a suspect was "fleeing from justice."

The changes were introduced by then-Sens. Phil Talmadge and George Fleming, who also introduced a bill banning the use of chokeholds in state prisons.

Talmadge said Fleming, an African-American legislator from Seattle, intended the law to limit use of deadly force against minorities. They drafted the justifiable-homicide bill based on the recent Supreme Court case law, although it was amended during debate to grant wider protections for use of force by police, Talmadge said.

"We both were roundly criticized by law enforcement," said Talmadge, who went on to serve on the state Supreme Court. "They weren't happy with the bills we proposed."

The effect of the law has been to limit prosecutions of police. The only known exception was a 2009 Snohomish County case in which a jury found an Everett police officer not guilty of killing a drunken driver. A civil claim in that case was settled Wednesday.

In that case, prosecutors sought to show malice by alleging that the officer said something like: "Time to end this; enough is enough," and then opened fire.

Samuel Walker, a University of Nebraska criminal justice emeritus professor, said prosecutions of police nationwide are so rare that many advocates have given up on that strategy and now focus on the police disciplinary process.

"Many activists want a conviction as their definition of justice," said Walker. "The brutal truth is you rarely get it."

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Hillyard neighbors say trailer is turning their neighborhood into a 'war zone'

    Hillyard neighbors say trailer is turning their neighborhood into a 'war zone'

    Monday, October 23 2017 8:30 PM EDT2017-10-24 00:30:18 GMT

    SPOKANE, Wash. - Neighbors and business owners in Hillyard tell KHQ they don't know how much more they can take. They said a motorhome is attracting all kinds of trouble. Piles of trash surround it, and neighbors said it is a magnet for crime. They said even human waste is going into the roadway. "It's a war zone," said one neighbor. "It's nothing but trouble," said another.

    >>

    SPOKANE, Wash. - Neighbors and business owners in Hillyard tell KHQ they don't know how much more they can take. They said a motorhome is attracting all kinds of trouble. Piles of trash surround it, and neighbors said it is a magnet for crime. They said even human waste is going into the roadway. "It's a war zone," said one neighbor. "It's nothing but trouble," said another.

    >>
  • Michigan teens charged with murder in highway rock incident

    Michigan teens charged with murder in highway rock incident

    Monday, October 23 2017 6:34 PM EDT2017-10-23 22:34:37 GMT

    FLINT, Mich. (AP) - Five teenagers have been charged with second-degree murder in the death of a Michigan man who was killed by a rock that smashed through the windshield of a vehicle in which he was riding. Genesee County Prosecutor David Leyton says the teens are 15 to 17 years old and are being charged as adults.

    >>

    FLINT, Mich. (AP) - Five teenagers have been charged with second-degree murder in the death of a Michigan man who was killed by a rock that smashed through the windshield of a vehicle in which he was riding. Genesee County Prosecutor David Leyton says the teens are 15 to 17 years old and are being charged as adults.

    >>
  • Police investigating after dead person found near Bowl and Pitcher

    Police investigating after dead person found near Bowl and Pitcher

    Monday, October 23 2017 8:05 PM EDT2017-10-24 00:05:06 GMT

    SPOKANE, Wash. - On October 23rd, shortly after 2:00 p.m., the Spokane Police Department was notified of a body found on the east side of the river by the walking bridge at the Bowl and Pitcher in Riverside State Park.  It was determined the person was deceased.

    >>

    SPOKANE, Wash. - On October 23rd, shortly after 2:00 p.m., the Spokane Police Department was notified of a body found on the east side of the river by the walking bridge at the Bowl and Pitcher in Riverside State Park.  It was determined the person was deceased.

    >>
HD DOPPLER 6i
/