DNA Testing Clears Osburn Man Of Rape
OSBURN, Idaho - An Osburn man who spent the last seven months in a Shoshone County Jail on charges of rape has now been released after DNA results came back negative and cleared him of the charge.
"Yes, he's happy, but he's also feeling very abused by the system at this point," said Gary Amendola, Justin Smith's lawyer. "From day one he asserted his innocence to everyone."
Gary Amendola represents Smith and has advised him not to speak of what happened. Unable to post bail, Smith sat in jail waiting for DNA results to come back from a long backlog of evidence at the state lab. Osburn Police says they arrested Smith when the alleged victim recognized his voice.
"There was very little evidence, and they were banking on the DNA," said Amendola.
Amendola claims the victim lied about being raped in the first place. Police say that is a possibility, but they have been unable to get in contact with her to ask any further questions, which is another reason they dropped the charges.
Smith's lawyer says after all of this he doesn't know if his client will ever get over what happened.
"We're very happy now that he is out and his name has been cleared, but I'm not sure any of us can appreciate what it was like for that to happen to a person," said Amendola.
Osburn Police say the case is still open despite the charges being dropped against Smith and the inability to contact the alleged victim.
KHQ's MIke Perry contributed to this report
Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>
New York State illegally moving convicted sex offenders from prisons into group homes with the developmentally disabledThree State agencies are involved in placing convicted sex offenders in group homes or hiding this information from the families and the general public>>
SPOKANE, Wash. - A problem within a solution – it’s a phrase so oxymoronic that it almost doesn’t make sense, but it’s crystal clear for a specific group of students at Lewis and Clark High School.>>
COEUR D'ALENE, Idaho - Multiple crews responded to a report of a cougar in a tree in Coeur d'Alene Monday. "I think time is on our side," Coeur d'Alene Police Detective, Jay Wilhelm, said. Indeed, it was. Coeur d'Alene Police, Fire and members of the Idaho Fish and Game cornered the male mountain lion, which was nested up in a tree near Qualfon on Ironwood Drive.>>
SANDPOINT, Idaho. First - it was a robocall, now a threat, targetting a Sandpoint newspaper and one of its writers, has surfaced on YouTube. "Ben Olson is a cancer on wholesome North Idaho," the video states. "And cancers must be burned out." The 56-second video clip shows a picture of Co-owner and Publisher of the Sandpoint Reader, Ben Olson, next to a stack of the newspaper he writes for. The papers are doused in a clear liquid then lit on fire.>>
- PULLMAN, Wash. - A man accused of hitting his ex-girlfriend on a rural Whitman County road in his truck and leaving her for dead has been sentenced to 9 months in jail.>>COLFAX, Wash. – Richard Pasma, the man accused of leaving his former girlfriend for dead along the Pullman-Albion Road last November, has been sentenced to nine months in jail after entering an Alford plea earlier this month.>>
SPOKANE, Wash. - Multiple fire crews from Spokane County and the Department of Natural Resources are working to mop up a series of fires that broke out along Interstate 90 west of Spokane. Crews on scene tell us that while they don't have an exact count, there were at least 3 different fires burning, all about 5-acres in size, along I-90 between exit 272 and 277.>>