'Catfished': The Story of One Woman Duped By a Fake Dating Profi - Spokane, North Idaho News & Weather KHQ.com

'Catfished': The Story of One Woman Duped By a Fake Dating Profile

Posted: Updated:

GRAND COULEE, Wash. -- When the outlandish story of Notre Dame football star Manti Te'o and his imaginary girlfriend broke in January, one word shot to the spotlight: "catfish."

"Catfish" is the name of a 2010 documentary about lonely hearts sucked into online romances, which are built on fake identities. The makers of the film developed a reality show for MTV of the same name. In Te'o's story, he fell for a girl he never met based on an elaborate social media profile. At the end of it all, Te'o was led to believe his so-called girlfriend had died. But that wasn't the worst of it. The story took an even more bizarre turn when Te'o found out his fake-dead girlfriend was actually a man.

While Te'o's story might be the most infamous example of "catfishing", he's certainly not the first.

"All of a sudden, it kind of scares you like 'What - how can this not be real?'" Tammy Starkey said.

At her home in Grande Coulee, Starkey still chokes up at the thought of falling into the same trap when all she wanted was to fall in love.

"After being divorced for five years, I just decided that, you know, I think it was time to try and find the person who might be my match," she explained.

Like so many single moms with a full-time job, Starkey felt crunched for time and limited in the local dating pool. "Around a small town, everybody knows everybody," she said.

So Starkey took a shot at finding love online. Right away, it appeared, love found her.

"I think it is an alluring thing," she said. "They tried to say sweet things - things you want to hear - and it's just 'Wow! Somebody wants to talk to me!'"

That's how she met the man who introduced himself as Justin Hatfield. He said he was an American soldier fighting for his country in Afghanistan and over the course of several months, they developed a courtship over the computer.

"You are reeled in. You're like 'wow, this is exciting. Butterflies in your stomach, sparkle in your eye, and you're like 'This is awesome.' And then you go for it."

Hatfield said that he planned to visit Starkey. However, that's when sweet-talking gave way to swindling. Hatfield claimed, in order to take leave, he needed Starkey to pay a $485 "processing fee". In a military document which Hatfield convinced Starkey was "official", he wrote the that Starkey's money would be "sent to the financial secretary through Western Union money transfer." Starkey's first instinct was to send him the money.

"I did! I was just like 'Oh my god!" Starkey explained.

Starkey didn't know at the time that that's not how the military works.

"You're so into love, you want to believe everything," she continued.

Unfortunately, it's a common romance ruse. The con artist, often based in Internet cafes in Africa, lifts a photo from social media sites and creates an entirely fake profile. These imposters aren't shy about luring in lonely hearts with pictures of military personnel, alive or dead.

Before Manti Te'o, Army Master Sgt. C.J. Grisham was the victim of online hoaxes when he'd discovered his picture was repeatedly and unwittingly plastered on dozens of dating profiles. Grisham, who's also a military blogger, now tracks these elusive imposters. Some reports say as many as one out of 10 profiles are romance scammers.

Back in Grand Coulee, Starkey never ended up sending any money. She said a friend realized what was happening and broke the news to her: the man she fell for was just a figment of someone else's imagination.

Starkey said, "I felt so heartbroken. My barriers went up. I felt like I couldn't trust again. It was just awful."

It wasn't until after a second stab at online dating, when another man pulled at her heart-strings for a hand out, that Starkey set out to find her online imposters. She checked Google and cross-referenced pictures and names. She never found the men who scammed her and likely never will.

she never did. and likely, never will.

"After this experience, it's not. It's not fun for me anymore," she said.

The man she fell for wasn't real but the pain was, and it was the hit to her heart that hurt the most.

Starkey has since given up on online dating. She now only dates in person and KHQ is pleased to report that she has since met someone. However, she shared her story as a cautionary tale so others who consider online dating will be extra vigilant about the people who they communicate with.

TIPS TO AVOID BEING THE VICTIM OF AN ONLINE SCAM:

* Military pictures should turn on your scam radar warning. Some of the biggest scams occur from supposed soldiers in the armed services with a believable sob story and a desperate need to settle down.

* Try and keep the conversation going on the dating site messaging system rather than being dragged off to Skype or MSN, at least initially.

* Use some basic conversational tests: If the person claims to be local, engage in a local-knowledge conversation (e.g. the weather, some nearby event, sports team, TV, or festival) and watch for mistakes. If the person is not claiming to be local, consider why he or she would want a long-distance relationship. Is there good reason, such as some particularly unusual common ground? If not, why aren't they restricting themselves to people a bit nearer to their current location?

* Look out for words like "dear" and old-fashioned romantic language, as well as badly formed sentences.

* Never, ever send money to anyone on a dating site, and especially avoid wiring cash.

* Always be on the lookout for get-rich-quick schemes. If it sounds too good to be true, then it's probably a scam.

RESOURCES TO BACKGROUND POSSIBLE SUITORS' STORIES:

*Internet Crimes Complaint Center .... http://www.ic3.gov/default.aspx

*To protect consumers, volunteers at www.romancescams.org/ post details of counterfeit dating profiles they've encountered: http://www.romancescams.org/

*Grisham's personal blog to track stolen soldiers' photos ... Http//asp.militarygear.com/2010/07/28/the-wall-of-shame/

*Google + face recognition feature called Find My Face can help reveal the real identity of someone in a photo posted online ...http://support.google.com/plus/bin/answer.py?hl=en&answer=2370300

*Zillow can cross-reference addresses of a potential online suitor ... http://www.zillow.com/

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • PHOTOS: Priest Lake lots auctioned off

    PHOTOS: Priest Lake lots auctioned off

    Thursday, August 28 2014 8:46 PM EDT2014-08-29 00:46:58 GMT
    PRIEST LAKE, Idaho - 61 cottages sites on Priest Lake were auctioned off in Coeur d'Alene on Thursday. >>
    PRIEST LAKE, Idaho - 61 cottages sites on Priest Lake were auctioned off in Coeur d'Alene on Thursday. For years, those already living on the sites leased the land from the State of Idaho, but the State was looking to sell. Residents already living on the sites showed up on Thursday to buy them back, and many were successful. 


    >>
  • THROWBACK THURSDAY: Johnny Depp in Spokane for 'Benny and Joon'

    THROWBACK THURSDAY: Johnny Depp in Spokane for 'Benny and Joon'

    Thursday, August 28 2014 4:06 PM EDT2014-08-28 20:06:32 GMT
    KHQ.COM - In the late 80's and early 90's Hollywood came to the Spokane area in a big way. One of the most well known films that was shot in the Lilac city was Benny and Joon. The 1992 movie included Aidan Quinn, Mary Stuart Masterson and Johnny Depp. KHQ was on set for a scene of the movie.
    >>
    KHQ.COM - In the late 80's and early 90's Hollywood came to the Spokane area in a big way. One of the most well known films that was shot in the Lilac city was Benny and Joon. The 1992 movie included Aidan Quinn, Mary Stuart Masterson and Johnny Depp. KHQ was on set for a scene of the movie.
    >>
  • Priest Lake Auction: Saying goodbye to home

    Priest Lake Auction: Saying goodbye to home

    Wednesday, August 27 2014 10:50 PM EDT2014-08-28 02:50:23 GMT
    PRIEST LAKE, Idaho - After years of obstacles for 61 Priest Lake lot lessees, the end comes on Thursday, August 28th. >>
    PRIEST LAKE, Idaho - After years of obstacles for 61 Priest Lake lot lessees, the end comes on Thursday, August 28th. People who have been leasing land from the state, some more than 40 years, will find out if they get to keep their property in an auction.Back in 2010, the State of Idaho decided to divest more than 300 lake lots on Priest Lake.
    >>
  • Top Stories from KHQTop StoriesMore>>

  • Priest River woman killed in early morning crash

    Priest River woman killed in early morning crash

    Friday, August 29 2014 2:14 PM EDT2014-08-29 18:14:59 GMT
    KOOTENAI COUNTY, Idaho - A Priest River woman was killed in an early morning car crash near Rathdrum on Friday.>>
    KOOTENAI COUNTY, Idaho - A Priest River woman was killed in an early morning car crash near Rathdrum on Friday. The Kootenai County Sheriff's Office told KHQ they arrived to the scene just off Nelson Loop Road, northwest of Rathdrum, just before 4:00 AM to find a 1997 Chevrolet that had rolled several times down an embankment>>
  • LOOK: Lung capacity of a smoker vs. non-smoker

    LOOK: Lung capacity of a smoker vs. non-smoker

    Friday, August 29 2014 1:31 PM EDT2014-08-29 17:31:24 GMT
    KHQ.COM - It's widely known that smoking isn't good for you, and we're not here to tell you what to do with your life, but we came across this Vine courtesy of Sploid and Mobitalent App that shows just how harmful a lifetime of smoking can be for your lungs.>>
    KHQ.COM - It's widely known that smoking isn't good for you, and we're not here to tell you what to do with your life, but we came across this Vine courtesy of Sploid and Mobitalent App that shows just how harmful a lifetime of smoking can be for your lungs. Does something like this demonstration make you want to quit smoking? Does it deter you from ever even starting? >>
  • Early morning house fire near Gary Middle School

    Early morning house fire near Gary Middle School

    Friday, August 29 2014 12:23 PM EDT2014-08-29 16:23:00 GMT
    KHQ.com - Spokane Firefighters responded to a house fire early Friday morning on the 800 block of East Joseph.Crews were called to the scene at 4:45am Friday near Gary Middle School. Firefighters were able to knock the fire down quickly.>>
    KHQ.com - Spokane Firefighters responded to a house fire early Friday morning on the 800 block of East Joseph.Crews were called to the scene at 4:45am Friday near Gary Middle School. Firefighters were able to knock the fire down quickly.>>