POLL: Who Is The Best Designated Hitter Of All-Time? - Spokane, North Idaho News & Weather KHQ.com

  • Who is the best designated hitter of all-time?

  • Thank you for participating in our poll. Here are the results so far:

    Edgar Martinez
    65%
    13 votes
    David Ortiz
    25%
    5 votes
    Harold Baines
    10%
    2 votes
    Other
    0%
    0 votes

POLL: Who Is The Best Designated Hitter Of All-Time?

Updated:

Coincidences in baseball sometimes feel a bit more like planned occurrences.

That might prove to be the case again on Wednesday in Seattle, when David Ortiz could collect the most hits by a designated hitter of all time. If Ortiz is unable to get a hit tonight, then he has another shot to achieve the milestone in the Emerald City on Thursday, as the Boston Red Sox wrap up a four-game series against the Mariners.

Why does it matter if Ortiz collects hit No. 1,689 and eclipses Harold Baines while in Seattle?

Well, it raises the question: Who is the best designated hitter of all-time? And that answer could very well be former Mariner Edgar Martinez.

Martinez is regarded by some as the best designated hitter ever to grace a baseball diamond. The seven-time All-Star hit .312 for his career with a .418 on-base percentage that ranks 17th all-time. Martinez was also a two-time American League batting champion and the recipient of five Silver Slugger Awards.

Meanwhile, Baines has 2,886 all-time hits (1,688 coming as a designated hitter). He was a great player in his own right and had a long, successful career.

Then, of course, is Ortiz, who is about to break the hits record for a designated hitter. Big Papi also owns the most home runs (419) of the trio and still has the potential for a few more seasons under his belt. 

So that brings us to the question of who is the best designated hitter of all-time? Is it Martinez? Or Baines? Or is it Ortiz? Make sure to vote in the poll above and let us know.

  • Pro SportsProMore>>

  • Former Zag Star, Indiana Fever's Haiden Palmer in Studio

    Former Zag Star, Indiana Fever's Haiden Palmer in Studio

    Former Gonzaga star guard and 29th overall pick in the 2014 Women's National Basketball League draft, Haiden Palmer, joined SWX's Michelle Dapper in studio on Tuesday, April 15. >>
    Former Gonzaga star guard and 29th overall pick in the 2014 Women's National Basketball League draft, Haiden Palmer, joined SWX's Michelle Dapper in studio on Tuesday, April 15. >>
  • Fielder, Rangers Blast Seattle

    Fielder, Rangers Blast Seattle

    Prince Fielder and Kevin Kouzmanoff hit back-to-back homers, Robbie Ross limited Seattle to five singles in seven-plus innings and the Texas Rangers beat the Mariners 5-0 Tuesday night.>>
    Prince Fielder and Kevin Kouzmanoff hit back-to-back homers, Robbie Ross limited Seattle to five singles in seven-plus innings and the Texas Rangers beat the Mariners 5-0 Tuesday night.>>
  • Beavan Recalled From Tacoma, Will Start Tonight

    Beavan Recalled From Tacoma, Will Start Tonight

    Seattle Mariners Executive Vice President General Manager of Baseball Operations Jack Zduriencik announced today that right-handed pitcher Blake Beavan has been recalled from AAA Tacoma and will be the starting pitcher in tonight’s game vs. the Rangers (5:05 pm PT/7:05 pm CT).>>
    Seattle Mariners Executive Vice President General Manager of Baseball Operations Jack Zduriencik announced today that right-handed pitcher Blake Beavan has been recalled from AAA Tacoma and will be the starting pitcher in tonight’s game vs. the Rangers (5:05 pm PT/7:05 pm CT).>>