Motion Filed To Allow Clay Starbuck To See His Three Young Kids - Spokane, North Idaho News & Weather KHQ.com

Motion Filed To Allow Clay Starbuck To See His Three Young Kids

SPOKANE, Wash. – Clay Starbuck's defense attorneys filed a motion Wednesday at the Spokane County Courthouse asking the judge to drop the no-contact order between Starbuck and his three youngest children that was upheld at his sentencing last week.

"The law does not allow for that," defense attorney Derek Reid told KHQ, adding that it would only make sense if the three children were victims of the crime in a legal sense, which they are not.

Starbuck was convicted in the 2011 murder of his ex-wife, Chanin Starbuck, in June and was sentenced to life in prison without parole last Thursday.

Throughout the course of the trial, Starbuck wasn't allowed to have contact with any of his five children, because they were called as witnesses in the case by the state.  However, that order was lifted for his two adult children when he was convicted.

Reid says they understood the order would also be lifted for the three younger children at Starbuck's sentencing; however, the state asked to uphold it and the judge agreed.

Throughout the sentencing, Clay Starbuck remained calm – except on this one issue.

"[The prosecutor] surprised us today," he told the court.  "We've been expecting the three minor children to be able to visit with me and now in the 11th hour people are trying to make a run to stop that, so I hope you'll take that into consideration."

The motion filed Wednesday says the no-contact order "interferes with Mr. Starbuck's fundamental right to parent," and goes on to say the issue is not the business of a sentencing court, but rather a "family and juvenile court" to decide.

It also cites other case law in which people convicted of crimes have been allowed to see their children, including Mary Kay Letourneau, the Burien, Washington, teacher who was convicted of rape after having a sexual relationship with her 12-year-old student.

"I did prepare several pages to speak about today but this is not the time or place to debate these issues," Clay Starbuck said at his sentencing.  "We're looking forward to a successful appeal and being able to get all the pertinent evidence admitted into court in a fair trial."

That appeal should be filed in the next week or two.  Then, it will be up to a Court of Appeals to decide whether Starbuck's murder conviction stands, or if an error was made during the proceedings that impacted his right to a fair trial, in which case he'd get a new trial.

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • How you can help the family of 8-year-old boy randomly stabbed at Spokane Valley gas station

    How you can help the family of 8-year-old boy randomly stabbed at Spokane Valley gas station

    Monday, November 19 2018 9:46 PM EST2018-11-20 02:46:19 GMT

    Several locals are trying to help the family of an eight-year-old boy, who was randomly stabbed at a gas station Saturday. Rayel Von Quade said she and three others (Salem Rose Sovereign, Quincey Brooks and Dani Loup) have been in touch with the Bush family. (KHQ has reached out to the family and have not heard back.) "They're, of course, very overwhelmed and stressed out right now and she's been dealing with a lot of messages from a lot of people coming through. But she says t...

    >>

    Several locals are trying to help the family of an eight-year-old boy, who was randomly stabbed at a gas station Saturday. Rayel Von Quade said she and three others (Salem Rose Sovereign, Quincey Brooks and Dani Loup) have been in touch with the Bush family. (KHQ has reached out to the family and have not heard back.) "They're, of course, very overwhelmed and stressed out right now and she's been dealing with a lot of messages from a lot of people coming through. But she says t...

    >>
  • E-coli concerns trigger recall of nearly 100,000 pounds of ground beef

    E-coli concerns trigger recall of nearly 100,000 pounds of ground beef

    Monday, November 19 2018 1:23 PM EST2018-11-19 18:23:43 GMT

    JBS USA has recalled nearly 100,000 pounds of ground beef due to concerns about possible e-coli contamination. The products have the establishment number Est.628 and were produced on October 24th. Products that were recalled were shipped to distributors in retail locations in California, Nevada, Oregon, Utah and Washington.  

    >>

    JBS USA has recalled nearly 100,000 pounds of ground beef due to concerns about possible e-coli contamination. The products have the establishment number Est.628 and were produced on October 24th. Products that were recalled were shipped to distributors in retail locations in California, Nevada, Oregon, Utah and Washington.  

    >>
  • Man said he was high on DXM when he randomly stabbed Spokane Valley boy

    Man said he was high on DXM when he randomly stabbed Spokane Valley boy

    Tuesday, November 20 2018 12:14 AM EST2018-11-20 05:14:38 GMT

    A man, claiming to be "the spawn of Lucifer," said he stabbed an eight-year-old boy because he "felt like he had to kill a child" and that it was "almost like a sacrifice." 30-year-old Bruce Derek Landahl was arrested Saturday for allegedly entering the HiCo store on Sprague, walking up to an eight-year-old boy playing on an iPad and stabbing him multiple times before the boy's father was able to stop him. 

    >>

    A man, claiming to be "the spawn of Lucifer," said he stabbed an eight-year-old boy because he "felt like he had to kill a child" and that it was "almost like a sacrifice." 30-year-old Bruce Derek Landahl was arrested Saturday for allegedly entering the HiCo store on Sprague, walking up to an eight-year-old boy playing on an iPad and stabbing him multiple times before the boy's father was able to stop him. 

    >>
HD DOPPLER 6i
/
  • Top Stories from KHQHomeMore>>

  • Police: Texas girl, 6, strangled baby brother as dad shopped

    Police: Texas girl, 6, strangled baby brother as dad shopped

    Tuesday, November 20 2018 8:47 AM EST2018-11-20 13:47:08 GMT

    HOUSTON - A Houston man has been charged with child abandonment after his 6-year-old daughter strangled her 1-year-old brother with a seat belt when he left them alone in a car.  Adrian Dreshuan Middleton was charged Friday in the May 20 killing in Houston.

    >>

    HOUSTON - A Houston man has been charged with child abandonment after his 6-year-old daughter strangled her 1-year-old brother with a seat belt when he left them alone in a car.  Adrian Dreshuan Middleton was charged Friday in the May 20 killing in Houston. A criminal complaint says the 26-year-old father told investigators he parked outside a thrift store, left the air conditioner on, gave the children water and snacks, and played a movie while he went shopping for clothes. 

    >>
  • Judge bars US from enforcing Trump asylum ban

    Judge bars US from enforcing Trump asylum ban

    Tuesday, November 20 2018 2:08 AM EST2018-11-20 07:08:59 GMT

    SAN FRANCISCO (AP) - A federal judge has temporarily barred the Trump administration from refusing asylum to immigrants who cross the southern border illegally.  U.S. District Judge Jon S. Tigar issued a temporary restraining order Monday after hearing arguments in San Francisco.  

    >>

    SAN FRANCISCO (AP) - A federal judge has temporarily barred the Trump administration from refusing asylum to immigrants who cross the southern border illegally.  U.S. District Judge Jon S. Tigar issued a temporary restraining order Monday after hearing arguments in San Francisco.  

    >>
  • Argument outside Chicago hospital prompts deadly shooting

    Argument outside Chicago hospital prompts deadly shooting

    Tuesday, November 20 2018 1:04 AM EST2018-11-20 06:04:49 GMT

    An argument outside a Chicago hospital turned deadly when a man pulled out a gun and killed an emergency room doctor with whom he was having a domestic relationship, then ran into the hospital and fatally shot a pharmacy resident and a police officer. 

    >>

    An argument outside a Chicago hospital turned deadly when a man pulled out a gun and killed an emergency room doctor with whom he was having a domestic relationship, then ran into the hospital and fatally shot a pharmacy resident and a police officer. 

    >>