Can Avondre Graham Face A Jury? Judge To Decide Tuesday - Spokane, North Idaho News & Weather KHQ.com

Can Avondre Graham Face A Jury? Judge To Decide Tuesday

Posted: Updated:

After being in jail for more than a year charged with in the stabbing death of his neighbor, Sharlotte McGill, a judge is about to decide whether Avondre Graham, 18, is competent to stand trial.

In court Monday, expert psychologists on both sides testified to Graham's mental disabilities, saying he is "mildly mentally retarded" with an IQ of roughly 60 – a number that hasn't changed much since he was 8 years old.

"Basically 99.5% of the population his age are brighter than he is," defense psychologist Dr. Bruce Fromkin told the court. "Even though Mr. Graham may be physically present in the courtroom, he's not mentally there, he's not going to understand much of what's transpiring."

Dr. Fromkin spent more than eight hours evaluating and testing Graham earlier this year, and his conclusion is that Graham is not competent to stand trial and would not be able to aid in his own defense because of his "severe intellectual disabilities."

However, the prosecution's psychologist, Dr. Nathan Henry, had a different opinion.

"He has adequate capacity to assist in his own defense," Dr. Henry told the court, based on his own evaluation with the 18-year-old murder suspect.

Dr. Henry also testified about Graham's history of depressive disorders, psychological problems, excessive use of alcohol and marijuana, suicidal thoughts and what he described as "emerging anti-social personality traits."

Graham's defense attorney, Tom Krzyminski, argued that the Washington Institute for Public Policy has deemed the testing tool used by Dr. Henry "substandard."

The decision now rests in the hands of Judge Maryann Moreno, who is scheduled to make her decision Tuesday morning.

If Graham is found competent, his trial will likely begin in the coming months. If he's not, he will likely be held either at the Spokane County Jail or Eastern State Hospital pending further testing and evaluation to see if he can become competent at a later time.

 

 

 

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Stolen bike didn't roll away unnoticed

    Stolen bike didn't roll away unnoticed

    Wednesday, August 20 2014 10:31 AM EDT2014-08-20 14:31:01 GMT
    SPOKANE, Wash. - When Paul Dannels finished his workout at the Downtown YMCA, he was surprised to see his bike was gone from the bike rack. "I was pretty upset, to be honest...mad, and discouraged, and depressed because I knew I couldn't replace it," said Dannels. A reporter for The Inlander happened to be at the YMCA when the bike was stolen.>>
    SPOKANE, Wash. - When Paul Dannels finished his workout at the Downtown YMCA, he was surprised to see his bike was gone from the bike rack. "I was pretty upset, to be honest...mad, and discouraged, and depressed because I knew I couldn't replace it," said Dannels. A reporter for The Inlander happened to be at the YMCA when the bike was stolen.
    >>
  • Another American hostage at risk by Islamic State after U.S. journalist beheaded

    Another American hostage at risk by Islamic State after U.S. journalist beheaded

    Wednesday, August 20 2014 10:15 AM EDT2014-08-20 14:15:08 GMT
    WASHINGTON (AP) - Militants with the Islamic State extremist group have beheaded American journalist James Foley and are threatening to kill another hostage in retaliation for U.S. air strikes in northern Iraq. The White House must now weigh the risks of adopting an aggressive policy to destroy the Islamic State against resisting any action that could result in the death of another American.>>
    WASHINGTON (AP) - Militants with the Islamic State extremist group have beheaded American journalist James Foley and are threatening to kill another hostage in retaliation for U.S. air strikes in northern Iraq. The White House must now weigh the risks of adopting an aggressive policy to destroy the Islamic State against resisting any action that could result in the death of another American.>>
  • HEALTH ALERT: Peanut butter recall for salmonella

    HEALTH ALERT: Peanut butter recall for salmonella

    Wednesday, August 20 2014 9:50 AM EDT2014-08-20 13:50:34 GMT
    KHQ.COM - The FDA announced a peanut butter recall on August 19th. nSpired Natural Foods, Inc. is voluntarily recalling certain retail lots of Arrowhead Mills® Peanut Butters, MaraNatha® Almond Butters and Peanut Butters and specific private label nut butters packaged in glass and plastic jars because they have the potential to be contaminated with Salmonella. >>>LINK TO RECALL LIST INSIDE>>>>>
    KHQ.COM - The FDA announced a peanut butter recall on August 19th. nSpired Natural Foods, Inc. is voluntarily recalling certain retail lots of Arrowhead Mills® Peanut Butters, MaraNatha® Almond Butters and Peanut Butters and specific private label nut butters packaged in glass and plastic jars because they have the potential to be contaminated with Salmonella. >>>LINK TO RECALL LIST INSIDE>>>
    >>
  • Top Stories from KHQTop StoriesMore>>

  • ALS ICE BUCKET CHALLENGE: More than $30 million raised since July 29th

    ALS ICE BUCKET CHALLENGE: More than $30 million raised since July 29th

    Thursday, August 21 2014 2:43 AM EDT2014-08-21 06:43:11 GMT
    KOOTENAI COUNTY, IDAHO- There's the ice bucket challenge, and then there's the ice FRONT LOADER challenge. That's what employees at Kootenai Electric Cooperative used. Three front loaders, actually.>>
    SPOKANE, Wash.- On Wednesday Spokane Mayor David Condon made good on his promise to take part in the ALS ice bucket challenge. Mayor Condon did the challenge around noon on the Gonzaga Prep football field. Members of the school's football team were also there. The mayor is a G-prep alumnus, and received the ice bucket challenge from several people.>>
  • PENTAGON CONFIRMS: Foley rescue attempt failed earlier this summer

    PENTAGON CONFIRMS: Foley rescue attempt failed earlier this summer

    Wednesday, August 20 2014 11:16 PM EDT2014-08-21 03:16:50 GMT
    WASHINGTON, D.C.- Wednesday afternoon the Pentagon released information about a rescue operation to free James Foley and other U.S. hostages held in Syria by Islamist militants. Several dozen troops flew in by helicopter, but couldn't find the hostages. One of those hostages was James Foley.>>
    WASHINGTON, D.C.- Wednesday afternoon the Pentagon released information about a rescue operation to free James Foley and other U.S. hostages held in Syria by Islamist militants. Several dozen troops flew in by helicopter, but couldn't find the hostages. One of those hostages was James Foley.>>
  • Spokane Police work to implement body cameras

    Spokane Police work to implement body cameras

    Wednesday, August 20 2014 10:23 PM EDT2014-08-21 02:23:21 GMT
    SPOKANE, Wash. - The Spokane Police Department plans to equip 15 to 20 officers with body cameras starting the first week of September. Police Chief Frank Straub says his team still has a lot of details to work out, but that this is something that has been on their radar for quite some time.>>
    SPOKANE, Wash. - The Spokane Police Department plans to equip 15 to 20 officers with body cameras starting the first week of September. Police Chief Frank Straub says his team still has a lot of details to work out, but that this is something that has been on their radar for quite some time.>>