Can Avondre Graham Face A Jury? Judge To Decide Tuesday - Spokane, North Idaho News & Weather KHQ.com

Can Avondre Graham Face A Jury? Judge To Decide Tuesday

After being in jail for more than a year charged with in the stabbing death of his neighbor, Sharlotte McGill, a judge is about to decide whether Avondre Graham, 18, is competent to stand trial.

In court Monday, expert psychologists on both sides testified to Graham's mental disabilities, saying he is "mildly mentally retarded" with an IQ of roughly 60 – a number that hasn't changed much since he was 8 years old.

"Basically 99.5% of the population his age are brighter than he is," defense psychologist Dr. Bruce Fromkin told the court. "Even though Mr. Graham may be physically present in the courtroom, he's not mentally there, he's not going to understand much of what's transpiring."

Dr. Fromkin spent more than eight hours evaluating and testing Graham earlier this year, and his conclusion is that Graham is not competent to stand trial and would not be able to aid in his own defense because of his "severe intellectual disabilities."

However, the prosecution's psychologist, Dr. Nathan Henry, had a different opinion.

"He has adequate capacity to assist in his own defense," Dr. Henry told the court, based on his own evaluation with the 18-year-old murder suspect.

Dr. Henry also testified about Graham's history of depressive disorders, psychological problems, excessive use of alcohol and marijuana, suicidal thoughts and what he described as "emerging anti-social personality traits."

Graham's defense attorney, Tom Krzyminski, argued that the Washington Institute for Public Policy has deemed the testing tool used by Dr. Henry "substandard."

The decision now rests in the hands of Judge Maryann Moreno, who is scheduled to make her decision Tuesday morning.

If Graham is found competent, his trial will likely begin in the coming months. If he's not, he will likely be held either at the Spokane County Jail or Eastern State Hospital pending further testing and evaluation to see if he can become competent at a later time.

 

 

 

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Kids walk home due to crowded bus

    Kids walk home due to crowded bus

    Friday, February 23 2018 8:18 PM EST2018-02-24 01:18:23 GMT
    School bus crash in Rathdrum, IDSchool bus crash in Rathdrum, ID
    School bus crash in Rathdrum, IDSchool bus crash in Rathdrum, ID

    Spokane Valley, Wash. As a father of four, Justin Hein was not happy that his 12-year-old daughter and five other students walked over a mile from Centennial Middle School to her home last week, “Kind of Frustrated,” said Hein. He continued by saying, “I had no clue that my kid was even nominated or telling to walk home from school with slippery ice, people driving, that aren't watching where they are going,  and trying to watch a cell phone. And I have to worry

    >>

    Spokane Valley, Wash. As a father of four, Justin Hein was not happy that his 12-year-old daughter and five other students walked over a mile from Centennial Middle School to her home last week, “Kind of Frustrated,” said Hein. He continued by saying, “I had no clue that my kid was even nominated or telling to walk home from school with slippery ice, people driving, that aren't watching where they are going,  and trying to watch a cell phone. And I have to worry

    >>
  • Liquor store clerks shoot armed robbery suspect, fight over gun

    Liquor store clerks shoot armed robbery suspect, fight over gun

    Saturday, February 24 2018 12:27 AM EST2018-02-24 05:27:46 GMT

    TULSA, Okla. - The owner of an Oklahoma liquor store has released graphic surveillance video showing a violent run-in with an armed robber.  KTUL reports that police responded to Forest Acres Liquor Store in Tulsa Thursday evening after the clerk called 911, saying they shot the suspect several times. The suspect took off before officers arrived, but he later showed up at a nearby hospital.  Police identified the suspect as Tyrone Lee, and 

    >>

    TULSA, Okla. - The owner of an Oklahoma liquor store has released graphic surveillance video showing a violent run-in with an armed robber.  KTUL reports that police responded to Forest Acres Liquor Store in Tulsa Thursday evening after the clerk called 911, saying they shot the suspect several times. The suspect took off before officers arrived, but he later showed up at a nearby hospital.  Police identified the suspect as Tyrone Lee, and 

    >>
  • One dead, one injured in crash on Highway 395 near Deer Park

    One dead, one injured in crash on Highway 395 near Deer Park

    Saturday, February 24 2018 1:33 AM EST2018-02-24 06:33:14 GMT

    DEER PARK, Wash. - Washington State Patrol is investigating a crash on Highway 395 near Deer Park. WSP officials said they were working to rescue two people who were trapped as a result of the crash Friday evening. Troopers said two cars were involved and there are serious injuries.  Highway 395 is blocked in both directions. Traffic is being divert southbound at Owens and northbound at Burrows.  Avoid the area if possible. 

    >>

    DEER PARK, Wash. - Washington State Patrol is investigating a crash on Highway 395 near Deer Park. WSP officials said they were working to rescue two people who were trapped as a result of the crash Friday evening. Troopers said two cars were involved and there are serious injuries.  Highway 395 is blocked in both directions. Traffic is being divert southbound at Owens and northbound at Burrows.  Avoid the area if possible. 

    >>
HD DOPPLER 6i
/
  • Top Stories from KHQHomeMore>>

  • NRA lashes out at boycott in wake of shooting

    NRA lashes out at boycott in wake of shooting

    Saturday, February 24 2018 7:16 PM EST2018-02-25 00:16:12 GMT

    NEW YORK (AP) - The National Rifle Association says companies that are severing ties with the gun rights group and its members are wrongly punishing them for a shooting at a Florida high school that claimed 17 lives.    In a statement sent Saturday, NRA spokeswoman Jennifer Baker said the group's 5 million members have long enjoyed discounts and benefits from many American corporations. 

    >>

    NEW YORK (AP) - The National Rifle Association says companies that are severing ties with the gun rights group and its members are wrongly punishing them for a shooting at a Florida high school that claimed 17 lives.    In a statement sent Saturday, NRA spokeswoman Jennifer Baker said the group's 5 million members have long enjoyed discounts and benefits from many American corporations. 

    >>
  • Recent amputee feels trapped in her Spokane home

    Recent amputee feels trapped in her Spokane home

    Saturday, February 24 2018 7:10 PM EST2018-02-25 00:10:41 GMT

     SPOKANE, Wash. - A woman who recently had to have her leg amputated feels trapped in her own home. She says the wheelchair ramp she needs to come and go is more than two decades old and rotting. With no where else to turn, she said, "Help Me Hayley." "My brain still thinks I have a leg," Tammy Eccles said. "It wants to move and I get sharp needle pains in the bottom of my foot." The hurt is at times unbearable for Eccles. "Sometimes 

    >>

     SPOKANE, Wash. - A woman who recently had to have her leg amputated feels trapped in her own home. She says the wheelchair ramp she needs to come and go is more than two decades old and rotting. With no where else to turn, she said, "Help Me Hayley." "My brain still thinks I have a leg," Tammy Eccles said. "It wants to move and I get sharp needle pains in the bottom of my foot." The hurt is at times unbearable for Eccles. "Sometimes 

    >>
  • Texas woman defecates in pants to hide drugs during arrest

    Texas woman defecates in pants to hide drugs during arrest

    Saturday, February 24 2018 6:37 PM EST2018-02-24 23:37:58 GMT

    CORSICANA, Texas (AP) - Police say a Texas woman attempted to hide evidence during an arrest by defecating in her pants and using the feces to conceal drugs.    Officers in Corsicana, about 55 miles (88 kilometers ) south of Dallas, were investigating a report of a theft at a grocery store on Wednesday when they attempted to subdue a female suspect and take her into custody.

    >>

    CORSICANA, Texas (AP) - Police say a Texas woman attempted to hide evidence during an arrest by defecating in her pants and using the feces to conceal drugs.    Officers in Corsicana, about 55 miles (88 kilometers ) south of Dallas, were investigating a report of a theft at a grocery store on Wednesday when they attempted to subdue a female suspect and take her into custody.

    >>