GERLACH TRIAL DAY 6: Defense Presents Their Case; Gerlach's Wife - Spokane, North Idaho News & Weather KHQ.com

GERLACH TRIAL DAY 6: Defense Presents Their Case; Gerlach's Wife Takes Stand

Posted: Updated:
During day 6 of the Gail Gerlach Trial, Gerlach's wife Sharon took the stand During day 6 of the Gail Gerlach Trial, Gerlach's wife Sharon took the stand
  • Also on KHQ.comMore>>

  • Gerlach Trial Day 5: Prosecution Rests Case

    Gerlach Trial Day 5: Prosecution Rests Case

    Monday, April 7 2014 5:20 PM EDT2014-04-07 21:20:20 GMT
    Monday, April 7 2014 5:20 PM EDT2014-04-07 21:20:20 GMT
    SPOKANE, Wash. - After the court was in recess on Friday, April 4th, Monday began the 5th day of the Gail Gerlach trial. The prosecution continued by calling multiple witnesses to the stand. KHQ's Kelsey Watts who has been covering this case from the start, was once again LIVE in court tweeting the events as they unfolded.>>
    SPOKANE, Wash. - After the court was in recess on Friday, April 4th, Monday began the 5th day of the Gail Gerlach trial. The prosecution continued by calling multiple witnesses to the stand. KHQ's Kelsey Watts who has been covering this case from the start, was once again LIVE in court tweeting the events as they unfolded.>>
  • GERLACH TRIAL DAY 4: Medical Examiner, Neighbors, And Forensic Team Leader Testify

    GERLACH TRIAL DAY 4: Medical Examiner, Neighbors, And Forensic Team Leader Testify

    Thursday, April 3 2014 3:15 PM EDT2014-04-03 19:15:01 GMT
    Thursday, April 3 2014 3:15 PM EDT2014-04-03 19:15:01 GMT
    SPOKANE, Wash. - Day 4 of the Gail Gerlach Trial began with Medical Examiner Dr. Sally Aiken taking the stand to testify.>>
    SPOKANE, Wash. - Day 4 of the Gail Gerlach Trial began with Medical Examiner Dr. Sally Aiken taking the stand to testify. Aiken began by explaining her background and experience, saying she has performed more than 7,000 autopsies during her career. Aiken responded to the scene where Gail Gerlach shot Brendon Kaluza-Graham to make sure the evidence and body were preserved, as well as to offer preliminary information about injuries.>>
  • Gerlach Trial Day 3: Opening Statements

    Gerlach Trial Day 3: Opening Statements

    Tuesday, April 1 2014 6:43 PM EDT2014-04-01 22:43:37 GMT
    Tuesday, April 1 2014 6:43 PM EDT2014-04-01 22:43:37 GMT
    SPOKANE, Wash. - Today is day 4 of the Gail Gerlach trial and the medical examiner and forensics experts are expected to testify. >>>KHQ's Kelsey Watts will be following this story until the end. Follow her in real time on Twitter, just search for @GerlachTrial. We will continue to update you on khq.com and in our all of our newscasts.>>
    SPOKANE, Wash. - Today is day 4 of the Gail Gerlach trial and the medical examiner and forensics experts are expected to testify. >>>KHQ's Kelsey Watts will be following this story until the end. Follow her in real time on Twitter, just search for @GerlachTrial. We will continue to update you on khq.com and in our all of our newscasts.>>
  • Jury Selection In Gerlach Trial Underway

    Jury Selection In Gerlach Trial Underway

    Monday, March 31 2014 6:33 PM EDT2014-03-31 22:33:26 GMT
    Monday, March 31 2014 6:33 PM EDT2014-03-31 22:33:26 GMT
    SPOKANE, Wash. - Jury selection in the trial of Gail Gerlach began on Monday. Gerlach is being charged with Manslaughter in the shooting death of Brendon Kaluza-Graham one year ago.>>
    SPOKANE, Wash. - Jury selection in the trial of Gail Gerlach began on Monday. Gerlach is being charged with Manslaughter in the shooting death of Brendon Kaluza-Graham one year ago. Gerlach left his SUV warming up in his driveway and says that he saw Kaluza-Graham get into his vehicle and begin driving away in an attempt to steal it.>>
  • Gerlach / Kaluza-Graham Shooting Coverage

    Gerlach / Kaluza-Graham Shooting Coverage

    Follow the latest developments on the March 2013 shooting of Brendon Kaluza-Graham.
    >>
    Follow the latest developments on the fatal shooting of Brendon Kaluza-Graham. 25-year-old Brendon Kaluza-Graham was shot by Gail Gerlach in March of 2013 as Kaluza-Graham was driving away in Gerlach's SUV. Gerlach says Kaluza-Graham was stealing the vehicle and he thought he saw the suspected car thief with gun.>>
SPOKANE, Wash. - Day 6 of the Gail Gerlach Manslaughter trial began with the defense team moving to dismiss the case, saying the prosecution didn't prove their case. The defense claimed it was based on Gerlach not being able to see through the SUV, and the witnesses called by the prosecution couldn't prove that. The judge ultimately sided with the prosecution, and ordered the trial to continue.

 The first witness the defense called was Gail Gerlach's wife, Sharon. The defense first asked her about all of the work equipment stored in the SUV. Sharon said it was organized, strapped down and not tall. While presenting their case, the prosecution claimed there was no way Gerlach couldn't seen a threatening motion from Brendon Kaluza-Graham because of all of Gerlach's work equipment. 

The defense team then questioned Sharon about her husband carrying a gun. Sharon said "it's senseless to have protection with you if you never have protection with you," when talking about her husband carrying a gun. She said it was her husband's 2nd Amendment right to bear arms. Sharon said when her husband noticed Kaluza-Graham stealing the SUV, he ran outside, and she was about two or three steps behind him, yelling for him to stop. 

Sharon said she saw Kaluza-Graham's arm come back as he leaned between the seats, and said she thought her husband was going to die because she thought Kaluza-Graham had a gun. Sharon said she heard her husband say either "Oh God," or "Oh gun." After the shooting Sharon said she called her boss to to say "someone stole our car and I think my husband shot him."

 After Gerlach shot Kaluza-Graham, the SUV crashed into a neighbor's garage down the street. Sharon says she then went down the street to see how bad the damage was to her neighbor's property and saw the SUV had crashed through the garage, dust and tree limbs were everywhere and there was a huge hole in the back window of the vehicle. Sharon also said she could see the drive clearly.

During cross-examination, Sharon said she doesn't want anything bad to happen to her husband. Prosecutors asked why she went to check on the property damage to her neighbors house, to which she replied, "I was shocked, operating on autopilot."

Sharon told prosecutors when she went to check on the car she walked around, looked in, saw Kaluza-Graham slumped over and not moving and assumed he was dead. Sharon said following the shooting, her husband said to her, "Honey I shot him, I think I hit him."

After Sharon's testimony, court was recessed for a short period of time. 

Following the recess, the defense team called Gaylan Warren, a forensic expert. The prosecution and defense then battle for about 30 minutes on whether or not Warren should be considered an expert. The judge eventually granted the status to Warren. Warren was called in to discuss the reconstruction of the scene. Warren said the scene should've been reconstructed to connect the dots between the gun and the "terminal ballistic event." 

Warren told the court he believes Gail Gerlach was at least four feet away from the SUV because there was no gunpowder on the car, but did say he could've been at a maximum distance of 60 feet away from where the glass shattered. 

Next, the defense called Robert Smith to the stand. Smith runs a gun training and education business in Post Falls and is also a Spokane paramedic. Smith said having two childhood friends attacked sparked his interest in guns for self-defense. Smith said he's had training on how to shoot and when to shoot dating back to 1980. Eventually, Smith was asked if he has a opinion as to whether Gerlach's use of force was justified, to which the prosecution objected. The judge ruled that Smith's testimony will be allowed because it would be his professional opinion. 

The jury was then instructed to note any potential bias and weigh "this piece of the puzzle" with all testimony and evidence. Smith then testified that he believes Gerlach may well have had a "perception of threat at the time of shooting." Smith continued that the 911 tape was "indicative of Gerlach's stress state." 
  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Motorcyclist dies in Hauser collision

    Motorcyclist dies in Hauser collision

    Thursday, June 21 2018 10:43 PM EDT2018-06-22 02:43:50 GMT

    A Spokane man has been pronounced deceased after his motorcycle was involved in a collision on Idaho State Highway 53 in Hauser on Thursday afternoon.

    >>

    A Spokane man has been pronounced deceased after his motorcycle was involved in a collision on Idaho State Highway 53 in Hauser on Thursday afternoon. 

    >>
  • Infant found at Seattle encampment in protective custody

    Infant found at Seattle encampment in protective custody

    Thursday, June 21 2018 10:26 PM EDT2018-06-22 02:26:38 GMT

    A 5-month-old infant found at a Seattle homeless encampment is in protective custody as police investigate child neglect. Seattle Police said Thursday on its blog that the child was removed in late May from an unsanctioned homeless encampment where people were reportedly using methamphetamine.    

    >>

    SEATTLE (AP) - A 5-month-old infant found at a Seattle homeless encampment is in protective custody as police investigate child neglect. Seattle Police said Thursday on its blog that the child was removed in late May from an unsanctioned homeless encampment where people were reportedly using methamphetamine.    

    >>
  • Two injured in Montana after swerving to avoid a kangaroo -- Really

    Two injured in Montana after swerving to avoid a kangaroo -- Really

    Thursday, June 21 2018 12:46 PM EDT2018-06-21 16:46:44 GMT
    File photo of a kangarooFile photo of a kangaroo

    DODSON, Mont. - Two people were injured in Montana Wednesday morning after swerving to avoid a kangaroo on the road.  Trooper Matt Finley with the Montana Highway Patrol said he thought it was a joke when he responded to the call, but when he arrived at about 4 a.m. he saw the kangaroo.  Trooper Finley said he learned there is a kangaroo farm west of Dodson. 

    >>

    DODSON, Mont. - Two people were injured in Montana Wednesday morning after swerving to avoid a kangaroo on the road.  Trooper Matt Finley with the Montana Highway Patrol said he thought it was a joke when he responded to the call, but when he arrived at about 4 a.m. he saw the kangaroo.  Trooper Finley said he learned there is a kangaroo farm west of Dodson. 

    >>
HD DOPPLER 6i
/
  • Top Stories from KHQHomeMore>>

  • Vantage Highway reopens, Milepost 22 Fire continues to burn to the north

    Vantage Highway reopens, Milepost 22 Fire continues to burn to the north

    Friday, June 22 2018 2:35 AM EDT2018-06-22 06:35:31 GMT
    Kittitas County Sheriff's OfficeKittitas County Sheriff's Office

    YAKIMA, Wash. (AP) - Evacuation notices have gone out to residents in about 30 homes because of a wildfire burning in central Washington. The state Department of Natural Resources said Thursday that the blaze about two miles north of Vantage near the Columbia River had burned nearly 8 square miles (21 square kilometers). The Yakima Herald reports that the fire dubbed milepost 22 started Wednesday afternoon and was 30 percent contained on Thursday afternoon. A ...

    >>

    YAKIMA, Wash. (AP) - Evacuation notices have gone out to residents in about 30 homes because of a wildfire burning in central Washington. The state Department of Natural Resources said Thursday that the blaze about two miles north of Vantage near the Columbia River had burned nearly 8 square miles (21 square kilometers). The Yakima Herald reports that the fire dubbed milepost 22 started Wednesday afternoon and was 30 percent contained on Thursday afternoon. A ...

    >>
  • Missoula man sentenced to 30 years for sex trafficking

    Missoula man sentenced to 30 years for sex trafficking

    Friday, June 22 2018 12:40 AM EDT2018-06-22 04:40:12 GMT

    BILLINGS, Mont. (AP) - A Missoula man has been sentenced to 30 years in federal prison after authorities say he lured women and girls into the commercial sex trade.  

    >>

    BILLINGS, Mont. (AP) - A Missoula man has been sentenced to 30 years in federal prison after authorities say he lured women and girls into the commercial sex trade.  

    >>
  • Report: Fire risk to Glacier chalet was 'underestimated'

    Report: Fire risk to Glacier chalet was 'underestimated'

    Thursday, June 21 2018 11:19 PM EDT2018-06-22 03:19:09 GMT

    MISSOULA, Mont. (AP) - A report indicates that fire managers had "underestimated" the risk posed to a Glacier National Park backcountry dormitory that burned last year. The Missoulian reports the investigation report by the National Park Service and U.S. Forest Service notes lessons learned following the lightning-caused fire that damaged the dining hall and destroyed the dormitory of the Sperry Chalet last August. A learning analysis notes that fire staff incorrec...

    >>

    MISSOULA, Mont. (AP) - A report indicates that fire managers had "underestimated" the risk posed to a Glacier National Park backcountry dormitory that burned last year. The Missoulian reports the investigation report by the National Park Service and U.S. Forest Service notes lessons learned following the lightning-caused fire that damaged the dining hall and destroyed the dormitory of the Sperry Chalet last August. A learning analysis notes that fire staff incorrec...

    >>