Judge Rules Samuel Hearing Sealed - Spokane, North Idaho News & Weather KHQ.com

Judge Rules Samuel Hearing Sealed

Posted: Updated:
Court documents were sealed by a judge this week in Eldon Samuel's murder case. Court documents were sealed by a judge this week in Eldon Samuel's murder case.
COEUR D'ALENE, Idaho -

A judge sealed the evidentiary portion of Eldon Samuel III's upcoming preliminary hearing during a status conference this afternoon.

The evidentiary portion is the majority of a preliminary hearing, where both parties present their evidence.

Samuel III is accused of murdering his father and brother last month.

Judge Clark Peterson addressed the parties this afternoon.

"I do not do this lightly," Judge Peterson said. "I do not remember ever having done this in a similar case."

The ruling to seal followed a motion filed earlier this month by Samuel's lawyer, requesting all records and proceedings in this case be sealed.

This morning, Judge Peterson held a status hearing on the motion at the Kootenai County Jail.

The defense argued that leaving the case open would fuel media sensationalism, and would lead to an unfair trial for the 14-year-old.

They claimed as a juvenile, Samuel III should have the right to confidentiality, as is the case with most juvenile trials.

Moreover, the defense argued that the charges, patricide and fratricide, reduced this case to a family tragedy rather than one of public interest.

The Samuel family, they said, including Eldon himself, would find it difficult to recover from this trial if more attention was drawn to the proceedings.

The Prosecution, who opposed the motion, argued that the defense lacked evidence and legal precedent to have the case sealed. They cautioned Judge Peterson not to make a ruling "based on emotion."

A third party -- KHQ's own legal team -- also addressed the motion in front of Judge Peterson.

They, too, took a stand against the defense's request, citing the public's first amendment right to public information, including court records.

In the end, Judge Peterson rationalized his decision by the consequences of each outcome.

"If I was wrong and failed to seal, there would be no remedy for this juvenile," he said. "But if I sealed when I should not have, the remedy is simply delayed information."

Eldon Samuel III, the judge said, is a remarkably unique defendant. If convicted, Samuel would only be the fifth minor ever tried and convicted of murder as an adult in Idaho.

The defense has also filed a continuance, delaying the preliminary hearing in this case. During today's hearing,

they indicated it will be at least two weeks before a preliminary hearing.

Jason Gray, KHQ's lawyer, said an appeal is possible after the judge enters an official written decision tomorrow.

He also said this decision only affects the preliminary hearing. If the case goes to trial after that, it will be moved to a district court, and

a separate motion must be filed for further proceedings to be sealed as well.

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Barista-stand owner faces prostitution charge

    Barista-stand owner faces prostitution charge

    Monday, September 1 2014 10:10 AM EDT2014-09-01 14:10:27 GMT
    EVERETT, Wash. (AP) - Authorities say the owner of bikini coffee stands in Washington state banked more than $2 million in just three years because her baristas were also selling sex acts. Snohomish County prosecutors charged 52-year-old former nude dancer Carmela Panico with promoting prostitution and money laundering, alleging that she was the madam of drive-thru brothels throughout the county north of Seattle.>>
    EVERETT, Wash. (AP) - Authorities say the owner of bikini coffee stands in Washington state banked more than $2 million in just three years because her baristas were also selling sex acts. Snohomish County prosecutors charged 52-year-old former nude dancer Carmela Panico with promoting prostitution and money laundering, alleging that she was the madam of drive-thru brothels throughout the county north of Seattle.
    >>
  • Throwback Thursday! Look At 'Sunshine Shelly' Through The Years!

    Throwback Thursday! Look At 'Sunshine Shelly' Through The Years!

    Thursday, March 20 2014 1:04 PM EDT2014-03-20 17:04:11 GMT
    KHQ.COM - It's throwback Thursday! Here is a slideshow we would like to share of Shelly Monahan through the years! For those of you who have been in Spokane for many years, and saw her through her "Sunshine Shelly" days, you will probably remember the Shelly from back in those days. Enjoy!>>
    KHQ.COM - It's throwback Thursday! Here is a slideshow we would like to share of Shelly Monahan through the years! For those of you who have been in Spokane for many years, and saw her through her "Sunshine Shelly" days, you will probably remember the Shelly from back in those days. Enjoy!>>
  • Joan Rivers' daughter: 'Keeping our fingers crossed'

    Joan Rivers' daughter: 'Keeping our fingers crossed'

    Monday, September 1 2014 10:33 AM EDT2014-09-01 14:33:34 GMT
    KHQ.COM - The Today Show has reported that Joan Rivers is now on life support. River's went into cardiac arrest at a New York doctor's office while she underwent a "minor throat surgery" on Thursday. Melissa Rivers said in a statement Sunday that "we are keeping our fingers crossed." She's thanking people for expressing their support.

    >>
    KHQ.COM - The Today Show has reported that Joan Rivers is now on life support. River's went into cardiac arrest at a New York doctor's office while she underwent a "minor throat surgery" on Thursday. Melissa Rivers said in a statement Sunday that "we are keeping our fingers crossed." She's thanking people for expressing their support.

    >>
  • Top Stories from KHQTop StoriesMore>>

  • Wildfire Victim Searches For Strength To Rebuild

    Wildfire Victim Searches For Strength To Rebuild

    Tuesday, September 2 2014 12:28 AM EDT2014-09-02 04:28:11 GMT
    ALTA LAKE, Wash. - "John Neuneker Sr. built almost everything on his property with his own two hands, including the home in which he and his wife Laurie raised their four children.“It was a family thing,” Neuneker told KHQ. “Not just my wife. My kids, all of us chipped in. We built the whole thing ourselves.” Their log cabin was one of many things Neuneker lost in the Carlton Complex Fire.>>
    ALTA LAKE, Wash. - "John Neuneker Sr. built almost everything on his property with his own two hands, including the home in which he and his wife Laurie raised their four children.“It was a family thing,” Neuneker told KHQ. “Not just my wife. My kids, all of us chipped in. We built the whole thing ourselves.” Their log cabin was one of many things Neuneker lost in the Carlton Complex Fire.>>
  • Body camera pilot program begins

    Body camera pilot program begins

    Monday, September 1 2014 10:23 PM EDT2014-09-02 02:23:48 GMT
    SPOKANE, Wash. - The Spokane Police Department will equip some officers with body cameras Monday, after Police Chief Frank Straub fast tracked pilot program. The Spokesman-Review reports 17 officers will receive the cameras designed to promote accountability and transparency within the police force. >>
    SPOKANE, Wash. - The Spokane Police Department will equip some officers with body cameras Monday, after Police Chief Frank Straub fast tracked pilot program. The Spokesman-Review reports 17 officers will receive the cameras designed to promote accountability and transparency within the police force. >>
  • Displaced Alta Lake family still searching for home

    Displaced Alta Lake family still searching for home

    Monday, September 1 2014 9:39 PM EDT2014-09-02 01:39:10 GMT
    The Gray family never felt squeezed into their 4 bedroom, two-story home Alta Lake home. It comfortably housed the parents and their six kids. Sadly, when their rental burned down, this family was left searching for a next step.>>
    The Gray family never felt squeezed into their 4 bedroom, two-story home Alta Lake home. It comfortably housed the parents and their six kids. Sadly, when their rental burned down, this family was left searching for a next step.>>