Supreme Court Ruling Upholds Prayer At Public Meetings - Spokane, North Idaho News & Weather KHQ.com

Supreme Court Ruling Upholds Prayer At Public Meetings

Posted: Updated:

WASHINGTON (AP) - The Supreme Court says prayers that open town council meetings do not violate the Constitution even if they routinely stress Christianity.

The court said in 5-4 decision Monday that the content of the prayers is not critical as long as officials make a good-faith effort at inclusion.

The ruling was a victory for the town of Greece, N.Y., outside of Rochester.

In 1983, the court upheld an opening prayer in the Nebraska legislature and said that prayer is part of the nation's fabric, not a violation of the First Amendment. Monday's ruling was consistent with the earlier one.

Justice Anthony Kennedy, writing for the majority, said the prayers are ceremonial and in keeping with the nation's traditions.

"The inclusion of a brief, ceremonial prayer as part of a larger exercise in civic recognition suggests that its purpose and effect are to acknowledge religious leaders and the institutions they represent, rather than to exclude or coerce nonbelievers," Kennedy said.

Justice Elena Kagan, in a dissent for the court's four liberal justices, said the case differs significantly from the 1983 decision because "Greece's town meetings involve participation by ordinary citizens, and the invocations given - directly to those citizens - were predominantly sectarian in content."

A federal appeals court in New York ruled that Greece violated the Constitution by opening nearly every meeting over an 11-year span with prayers that stressed Christianity.

From 1999 through 2007, and again from January 2009 through June 2010, every meeting was opened with a Christian-oriented invocation. In 2008, after residents Susan Galloway and Linda Stephens complained, four of 12 meetings were opened by non-Christians, including a Jewish layman, a Wiccan priestess and the chairman of the local Baha'i congregation.

A town employee each month selected clerics or lay people by using a local published guide of churches. The guide did not include non-Christian denominations, however. The appeals court found that religious institutions in the town of just under 100,000 people are primarily Christian, and even Galloway and Stephens testified they knew of no non-Christian places of worship there.

The two residents filed suit and a trial court ruled in the town's favor, finding that the town did not intentionally exclude non-Christians. It also said that the content of the prayer was not an issue because there was no desire to proselytize or demean other faiths.

But a three-judge panel of the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals said that even with the high court's 1983 ruling, the practice of having one Christian prayer after another amounted to the town's endorsement of Christianity.

Kennedy, however, said judges should not be involved in evaluating the content of prayer because it could lead to legislatures requiring "chaplains to redact the religious content from their message in order to make it acceptable for the public sphere."

He added, "Government may not mandate a civic religion that stifles any but the most generic reference to the sacred any more than it may prescribe a religious orthodoxy."

Kennedy himself was the author an opinion in 1992 that held that a Christian prayer delivered at a high school graduation did violate the Constitution. The justice said Monday there are differences between the two situations, including the age of the audience and the fact that attendees at the council meeting may step out of the room if they do not like the prayer.

The case is Greece v. Galloway, 12-696


  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • PHOTOS: Priest Lake lots heading to auction

    PHOTOS: Priest Lake lots heading to auction

    Thursday, August 28 2014 11:58 AM EDT2014-08-28 15:58:24 GMT
    PRIEST LAKE, Idaho - On Thursday, 61 cottages sites on Priest Lake will be auctioned off in Coeur d'Alene beginning at 1:00pm. >>
    PRIEST LAKE, Idaho - On Thursday, 61 cottages sites on Priest Lake will be auctioned off in Coeur d'Alene beginning at 1:00pm. For years, those already living on the sites leased the land from the State of Idaho, but now the State is looking to sell. Residents already living on the sites can bid to buy them back, however many have told KHQ they are preparing for their last few days at the lake.>>
  • Priest Lake Auction: Saying goodbye to home

    Priest Lake Auction: Saying goodbye to home

    Wednesday, August 27 2014 10:50 PM EDT2014-08-28 02:50:23 GMT
    PRIEST LAKE, Idaho - After years of obstacles for 61 Priest Lake lot lessees, the end comes on Thursday, August 28th. >>
    PRIEST LAKE, Idaho - After years of obstacles for 61 Priest Lake lot lessees, the end comes on Thursday, August 28th. People who have been leasing land from the state, some more than 40 years, will find out if they get to keep their property in an auction.Back in 2010, the State of Idaho decided to divest more than 300 lake lots on Priest Lake.
    >>
  • VIRAL VIDEO: Tribute to Robin Wililams at the Emmy's

    VIRAL VIDEO: Tribute to Robin Wililams at the Emmy's

    Thursday, August 28 2014 11:46 AM EDT2014-08-28 15:46:43 GMT
    KHQ.COM - If you missed the Emmy's on Monday night, you missed a great tribute to Robin Williams. Billy Crystal paid tribute to his friend and the man that filled millions of homes with laughter saying, "It's very hard to talk about him in the past because he was so present in all of our lives.">>
    KHQ.COM - If you missed the Emmy's on Monday night, you missed a great tribute to Robin Williams. Billy Crystal paid tribute to his friend and the man that filled millions of homes with laughter saying, "It's very hard to talk about him in the past because he was so present in all of our lives.">>
  • Top Stories from KHQTop StoriesMore>>

  • UPDATE: Dog shot & killed by Spokane Valley deputy

    UPDATE: Dog shot & killed by Spokane Valley deputy

    Thursday, August 28 2014 7:02 PM EDT2014-08-28 23:02:36 GMT
    SPOKANE VALLEY, Wash. - A Spokane County deputy shot and killed a dog Wednesday afternoon in Spokane Valley after he said the dog attacked him.>>
    SPOKANE VALLEY, Wash. - A Spokane County deputy shot and killed a dog Wednesday afternoon in Spokane Valley after he said the dog attacked him. The Sheriff's Office told KHQ the deputy was trying to return property to the home near Sprague and Henry.  INSIDE>>>|RAW INTERVIEW from the dog's owner|>>
  • WATCH: President Obama addresses nation on international militant threats

    WATCH: President Obama addresses nation on international militant threats

    Thursday, August 28 2014 5:08 PM EDT2014-08-28 21:08:30 GMT
    KHQ.COM - President Obama addressed the nation on Thursday about the militant threats in Syria, Iraq, Ukraine and Russia. >>>WATCH what he said>>>>>
    KHQ.COM - President Obama addressed the nation on Thursday about the militant threats in Syria, Iraq, Ukraine and Russia. >>>WATCH what he said>>>
    >>
  • Police officials: Joan Rivers rushed to hospital

    Police officials: Joan Rivers rushed to hospital

    Thursday, August 28 2014 4:35 PM EDT2014-08-28 20:35:02 GMT
    NEW YORK (AP) - Comedian Joan Rivers is in a New York City hospital, according to police and hospital officials who say she was rushed there from a doctor's office after going into cardiac arrest. >>
    NEW YORK (AP) - Comedian Joan Rivers is in a New York City hospital, according to police and hospital officials who say she was rushed there from a doctor's office after going into cardiac arrest. There's no word on the condition of the 81-year-old.
    >>