Judge grants plea deal for Preston Maher - Spokane, North Idaho News & Weather KHQ.com

Judge grants plea deal for Preston Maher

Posted: Updated:
ADVERTISEMENT
Bookmark and Share
During the plea hearing for Preston Maher, the courtroom was packed with supporters for Josie Freier and McKenzie Mott. During the plea hearing for Preston Maher, the courtroom was packed with supporters for Josie Freier and McKenzie Mott.
Preston Maher leaving the courtroom after judge granted plea of 60 days juvenile detention. Preston Maher leaving the courtroom after judge granted plea of 60 days juvenile detention.
McKenzie Mott's mother embraced after leaving courtroom. Judge declined her family's request for a longer sentence. McKenzie Mott's mother embraced after leaving courtroom. Judge declined her family's request for a longer sentence.
Preston Maher's father says he & son finally had chance to apologize to families today. Preston Maher's father says he & son finally had chance to apologize to families today.
KHQ.COM - - Thursday morning, Preston Maher plead guilty to two counts of vehicular homicide in the deaths of Josie Freier and McKenzie Mott and the judge granted the plea deal. This means Maher will serve 60 days  in juvenile detention. Maher has been given one week to get his affairs in order before he must report to the juvenile detention center.

The courtroom was packed with dozens showing up in support of the two girls who died last October in a car crash. Maher was driving the car and was attempting to do what is known as the "Ponderosa Jump" when he lost control of the vehicle and crashed into a tree.

The sentence negotiated in the plea bargain is less than the usual standard for vehicular homicide charges. The prosecution said they looked at accountability and rehabilitation in reaching the deal and that after reviewing and analyzing the case, they believed it was appropriate to lower the sentence.

The defense addressed the fact that no alcohol or drugs were involved. They said Maher was not driving recklessly but that he was simply an inexperienced driver and the road was poorly lit and dangerous. The defense also said the Maher family tried to reach out to the victims' families but were turned away.

Family members, friends and professionals testified on Preston's character and level of remorse including his counselor, father, the family pastor, a friend of the family who was in a similar accident and a teacher. 

Maher's Counselor reported that he has been seeing Preston for depression which he did not suffer from until the accident. The counselor said Maher feels guilt on a daily basis. The defense then read a letter to the court that Maher had given to his counselor. In the letter, Maher said he is "plagued with guilt and self-condemnation."

The defense also argued that the juvenile facility would be harmful to Preston Maher and it would disconnect him from his family. They also pointed out that Maher has deep remorse and is unlikely to reoffend.

Preston Maher's father took the stand and was very emotional while giving his statements. He said the accident has left their family devastated and that Preston puts on mask everyday to avoid a breakdown. In an apology to the victims' families he said, "if Preston and I have given the impression we're not sorry, that's far from the truth. We just hope you accept our apology."

The Maher family's pastor then said that he can attest the Maher family has shown a lot of remorse. The pastor said that many look up to Preston and that what's best for him is to have a minimal sentence.

A friend of the Maher family who was in a similar accident said he knows "Preston will have a life sentence." Preston's teacher said that "he is a wonderful young man and that few have his integrity."

Family and friends then testified on behalf of Josie and McKenzie.

Josie's father, Rick Freier, took the stand saying, "this is a bad thing and we're stuck in the middle of it." Rick said his family was informed of the sentencing guidelines but didn't find out until later that a plea deal was on the table. He wanted to go to trial for the girls and he said he doesn't "want anything bad to happen to Maher...I just think in the interest of the people of WA, there needs to be a sentence in guidelines. I hope he takes the blessing he got surviving and does something amazing with it," he said. He also said he feels guilt and he doesn't know how any of them are going to get through this.

Josie's sister said, "my heart is broken and my life is empty without Josie." She feels the sentence should be more severe and that Maher's behavior is not worth a 60 day sentence. She said it's "not about anger or revenge, it's about the law."

McKenzie's mother then took the stand saying "I only have memories, smells, the sound of her voice and dreams that wake me up at night. That's what brings her back. We live with this everyday. Our hearts are forever broken." She said her grandson asks his mom to go to heaven and bring McKenzie back. "We know there's no punishment that will ever seem just," she just wants accountability. She said all kids are good but their actions aren't. They must live with the repercussions. "This was a choice...McKenzie was amazing and exceptional... I can't tell you what our lives have been like the last year," her mother said. "They are gone forever, but not forgotten."

A firefighter then took the stand saying, "please help me when I go to work to not go to these accidents." He thinks a standard is being set with Preston.

Preston Maher finally took the stand saying, "words can't express how sorry I am. I think about what I've done. I take full responsibility. I continue to think about all the time I spent with the girls...McKenzie had a great sense of humor...I miss talking and laughing with Josie."






  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • 13 semi-trucks park under Detroit overpass to help man considering suicide

    13 semi-trucks park under Detroit overpass to help man considering suicide

    Tuesday, April 24 2018 12:41 PM EDT2018-04-24 16:41:55 GMT

    DETROIT - 13 semi-truck drivers parked their big rigs under a highway overpass early Tuesday morning to help shorten the fall of a man who was threatening to jump.  All lanes of Highway 696 were closed early Tuesday morning after a call came in just before 1:00 a.m. of a man threatening to jump.  

    >>

    DETROIT - 13 semi-truck drivers parked their big rigs under a highway overpass early Tuesday morning to help shorten the fall of a man who was threatening to jump.  All lanes of Highway 696 were closed early Tuesday morning after a call came in just before 1:00 a.m. of a man threatening to jump.  

    >>
  • Pierce County woman wakes up to stranger in her house rubbing her face

    Pierce County woman wakes up to stranger in her house rubbing her face

    Tuesday, April 24 2018 1:11 AM EDT2018-04-24 05:11:05 GMT

    PIERCE COUNTY, Wash. - A Pierce County woman was terrified over the weekend when she woke up to a stranger in her house rubbing her face. She ran to her neighbor's house and the neighbor contacted the Pierce County Sheriff's Office at around 5:30 a.m. on Sunday. Arriving deputies spoke with the neighbor who called 911. 

    >>

    PIERCE COUNTY, Wash. - A Pierce County woman was terrified over the weekend when she woke up to a stranger in her house rubbing her face. She ran to her neighbor's house and the neighbor contacted the Pierce County Sheriff's Office at around 5:30 a.m. on Sunday. Arriving deputies spoke with the neighbor who called 911. 

    >>
  • Thief steals military man’s gift for little brother

    Thief steals military man’s gift for little brother

    Tuesday, April 24 2018 2:09 AM EDT2018-04-24 06:09:15 GMT

    SPOKANE, Wash. - A Spokane mother is heartbroken because what a thief took from her family was so much more than just a piece of mail. One of her sons serving in the military, stays connected with his little brother through video games, so he sent him one as a gift. However, the little brother never got it because the thief took it right off their front porch.

    >>

    SPOKANE, Wash. - A Spokane mother is heartbroken because what a thief took from her family was so much more than just a piece of mail. One of her sons serving in the military, stays connected with his little brother through video games, so he sent him one as a gift. However, the little brother never got it because the thief took it right off their front porch.

    >>
HD DOPPLER 6i
/
  • Top Stories from KHQHomeMore>>

  • Big gator turns heads outside Florida middle school

    Big gator turns heads outside Florida middle school

    Tuesday, April 24 2018 7:09 PM EDT2018-04-24 23:09:19 GMT

    VOLUSIA COUNTY, Fla. - A brief video of a large gator strolling past a Florida middle school is turning heads this week. It happened around 7:30 p.m. Sunday. Witnesses who spotted the gator said it caused a bit of a traffic jam around Deltona Middle School, which is usually pretty deserted on a Sunday evening.

    >>

    VOLUSIA COUNTY, Fla. - A brief video of a large gator strolling past a Florida middle school is turning heads this week. It happened around 7:30 p.m. Sunday. Witnesses who spotted the gator said it caused a bit of a traffic jam around Deltona Middle School, which is usually pretty deserted on a Sunday evening.

    >>
  • Spokane man who stole financial info from mail boxes sentenced to prison

    Spokane man who stole financial info from mail boxes sentenced to prison

    Tuesday, April 24 2018 6:49 PM EDT2018-04-24 22:49:30 GMT

    SPOKANE, Wash. - A 22-year-old Spokane man was sentenced Tuesday to a year in federal prison and five years probation after he pleaded guilty last year to conspiracy to commit bank fraud. According to information disclosed during court proceedings, Brendon M. McCullough and his conspirators stole credit and debit cards, check and PINs from mailboxes and used that stolen financial information to withdraw funds' from victims' bank accounts.

    >>

    SPOKANE, Wash. - A 22-year-old Spokane man was sentenced Tuesday to a year in federal prison and five years probation after he pleaded guilty last year to conspiracy to commit bank fraud. According to information disclosed during court proceedings, Brendon M. McCullough and his conspirators stole credit and debit cards, check and PINs from mailboxes and used that stolen financial information to withdraw funds' from victims' bank accounts.

    >>
  • Lincoln County inmate tries to escape, doesn't get far

    Lincoln County inmate tries to escape, doesn't get far

    Tuesday, April 24 2018 6:31 PM EDT2018-04-24 22:31:02 GMT
    Escape attempt by convicted Idaho killer fails.Escape attempt by convicted Idaho killer fails.

    LINCOLN COUNTY, Wash. - The Lincoln County Sheriff's Office reports a female inmate tried to escape while she was being taken back to jail after a court appearance Tuesday. Deputies say that around 11 a.m., the inmate was being escorted across the street from Superior Court when she tried to make a break for it. She was being escorted by an armed deputy and two other suspects. She was in belly chains, ankle restraints and handcuffs when she tried to run.

    >>

    LINCOLN COUNTY, Wash. - The Lincoln County Sheriff's Office reports a female inmate tried to escape while she was being taken back to jail after a court appearance Tuesday. Deputies say that around 11 a.m., the inmate was being escorted across the street from Superior Court when she tried to make a break for it. She was being escorted by an armed deputy and two other suspects. She was in belly chains, ankle restraints and handcuffs when she tried to run.

    >>