Gonzaga community responds to Columbia review of retracted Rolli - Spokane, North Idaho News & Weather KHQ.com

Gonzaga community responds to Columbia review of retracted Rolling Stone story

Posted: Updated:
Phi Kappa Psi, the fraternity at the center of the original article, says it will take all available legal action against the magazine. Phi Kappa Psi, the fraternity at the center of the original article, says it will take all available legal action against the magazine.

At the beginning of this week, the Columbia University Graduate School of Journalism at Columbia published what's being called a scathing review of the "Rape on Campus" story published by Rolling Stone back in November. The original story was about a gang rape at a fraternity house at the University of Virginia but the review discredited the story, and found that the author and editors relied solely on only one source - the victim, a student identified only as "Jackie." 

The review pointed out that the author and editor failed to exercise some of the most basic journalistic principles, fact-checking being one of them. And now, Phi Kappa Psi, the fraternity at the center of the original article, says it will take all available legal action against the magazine.

The original story sent shockwaves through the UVa. community, and through college campuses across the country. Now, even though this story has been retracted, the issue remains: sexual assault is a problem on college campuses from Charlottesville, Virginia all the way to Spokane, Washington.

Shortly after the Columbia review came out, the New York Times published an article that quoted a young woman who attended UVa., is a survivor of sexual assault, and now works at the university. She said another reason why this article was so flawed was because the author chose to focus on this most extreme story of campus rape, as if to say the more nuanced accounts of campus rape were not "real" enough to represent rape culture. This belief, she said, is part of the problem.

Meg Besch, a GU senior who is actively working with her school administrators to craft better campus policies about sexual assault and the meaning of "consent" said she desperately wishes this story was not a case of false reporting but she said she also hopes students continue to come forward with their personal stories.

"False reporting is not core of issue," she said. "It's unfortunate how this came out, but it's important to focus on the fact that people get hurt, and we need to do better, by them."

And although the facts were wrong in this case, she pointed out that false allegations of rape are rare.

"The only way rape culture is going to change is if people challenge it," said Besch. " The only way policies will get better is if we challenge them and say this is where the University failed me, or the police failed me, or investigative journalism let me down."

Gonzaga's broadcast professor Dan Garrity said he hopes his journalism students are able to learn from the egregious mistakes the magazine made.

"The reporter, I imagine, wanted to take a stand on something horrible: sexual assault," he said. "But the danger, when you quit asking questions, when you know in your heart it's bad, you don't scrutinize all aspects of story...and that's your job, as a reporter."

He does want his students to continue to tell stories that have the potential for great change, even if the subject matter is hard.

"I want my students to know that their job is to do this better," said Garrity. "I bet the journalists of the future will come up with a way - they need to come up with a way, to make a difference here."

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • One man dead, another arrested after shooting near Post Falls

    One man dead, another arrested after shooting near Post Falls

    Sunday, October 21 2018 10:57 AM EDT2018-10-21 14:57:39 GMT

    POST FALLS, Idaho - Kootenai County Deputies arrested a man for involuntary manslaughter after they say he shot and killed another man Saturday evening near Post Falls. Deputies responded to reports of a shooting on Gallatin Way near Post Falls just before 7 pm. Deputies and medical personnel arrived and found a man, identified as Tyler S. Liles, with a single gunshot wound.

    >>

    POST FALLS, Idaho - Kootenai County Deputies arrested a man for involuntary manslaughter after they say he shot and killed another man Saturday evening near Post Falls. Deputies responded to reports of a shooting on Gallatin Way near Post Falls just before 7 pm. Deputies and medical personnel arrived and found a man, identified as Tyler S. Liles, with a single gunshot wound.

    >>
  • Indianapolis Zoo lioness kills father of her three cubs

    Indianapolis Zoo lioness kills father of her three cubs

    Sunday, October 21 2018 6:54 PM EDT2018-10-21 22:54:30 GMT
    Indianapolis Zoo - FacebookIndianapolis Zoo - Facebook

    INDIANAPOLIS - A lion on loan from the San Diego Zoo died in a fight with another lion at the Indianapolis Zoo on Monday, zoo officials said. According to the zoo, Nyack, a 10-year-old lion, was killed by his longtime mate, Zuri, in the outdoor yard Monday morning before the menagerie opened to the public. 

    >>

    INDIANAPOLIS - A lion on loan from the San Diego Zoo died in a fight with another lion at the Indianapolis Zoo on Monday, zoo officials said. According to the zoo, Nyack, a 10-year-old lion, was killed by his longtime mate, Zuri, in the outdoor yard Monday morning before the menagerie opened to the public. 

    >>
  • Remembering Eddie Daniels: memorial held in honor of Spokane teenager

    Remembering Eddie Daniels: memorial held in honor of Spokane teenager

    Monday, October 22 2018 2:04 AM EDT2018-10-22 06:04:38 GMT
    Hundreds gather inside Healing Room Ministries Office at 115 East Pacific Avenue. Many attendees had to stand because the facility ran out of chairs.Hundreds gather inside Healing Room Ministries Office at 115 East Pacific Avenue. Many attendees had to stand because the facility ran out of chairs.
    Hundreds of different people from various backgrounds gathered together for the same purpose on Sunday: honoring and remembering the life of Eddie Daniels, the 15-year-old shot and killed in downtown Spokane on Wednesday night. Members of Daniels' family were also in attendance, including his mother. She's raised Daniels' and his siblings alone since her husband died over a decade ago, according to multiple friends of the family. When Daniels' mother arrived and stepped out...>>
    Hundreds of different people from various backgrounds gathered together for the same purpose on Sunday: honoring and remembering the life of Eddie Daniels, the 15-year-old shot and killed in downtown Spokane on Wednesday night. Members of Daniels' family were also in attendance, including his mother. She's raised Daniels' and his siblings alone since her husband died over a decade ago, according to multiple friends of the family. When Daniels' mother arrived and stepped out...>>
HD DOPPLER 6i
/
  • Top Stories from KHQHomeMore>>

  • Remembering Eddie Daniels: memorial held in honor of Spokane teenager

    Remembering Eddie Daniels: memorial held in honor of Spokane teenager

    Monday, October 22 2018 2:04 AM EDT2018-10-22 06:04:38 GMT
    Hundreds gather inside Healing Room Ministries Office at 115 East Pacific Avenue. Many attendees had to stand because the facility ran out of chairs.Hundreds gather inside Healing Room Ministries Office at 115 East Pacific Avenue. Many attendees had to stand because the facility ran out of chairs.
    Hundreds of different people from various backgrounds gathered together for the same purpose on Sunday: honoring and remembering the life of Eddie Daniels, the 15-year-old shot and killed in downtown Spokane on Wednesday night. Members of Daniels' family were also in attendance, including his mother. She's raised Daniels' and his siblings alone since her husband died over a decade ago, according to multiple friends of the family. When Daniels' mother arrived and stepped out...>>
    Hundreds of different people from various backgrounds gathered together for the same purpose on Sunday: honoring and remembering the life of Eddie Daniels, the 15-year-old shot and killed in downtown Spokane on Wednesday night. Members of Daniels' family were also in attendance, including his mother. She's raised Daniels' and his siblings alone since her husband died over a decade ago, according to multiple friends of the family. When Daniels' mother arrived and stepped out...>>
  • SVFD extinguishes portable toilet fire next to Trentwood Elementary

    SVFD extinguishes portable toilet fire next to Trentwood Elementary

    Sunday, October 21 2018 9:24 PM EDT2018-10-22 01:24:02 GMT

    SPOKANE VALLEY, Wash. - Spokane Valley Firefighters were able to prevent a fire from spreading after a portable toilet wound up in flames next to Trentwood Elementary on Sunday afternoon. Crews responded to a report of a portable building on fire around 4 p.m. Sunday. A full response was prompted after black smoke was seen from Trent and Sullivan. 

    >>

    SPOKANE VALLEY, Wash. - Spokane Valley Firefighters were able to prevent a fire from spreading after a portable toilet wound up in flames next to Trentwood Elementary on Sunday afternoon. Crews responded to a report of a portable building on fire around 4 p.m. Sunday. A full response was prompted after black smoke was seen from Trent and Sullivan. 

    >>
  • Domestic violence suspect shot, killed in Spanaway

    Domestic violence suspect shot, killed in Spanaway

    Sunday, October 21 2018 8:03 PM EDT2018-10-22 00:03:11 GMT

    SPANAWAY, Washington (AP) - Pierce County sheriff's detectives are investigating the fatal shooting of an armed domestic violence suspect by sheriff's deputies.  KIRO-TV reports the shooting occurred Saturday night in Spanaway, south of Tacoma.  Deputies responded to a 911 call just before 9:30 p.m. from a woman reporting domestic violence. She said her boyfriend was intoxicated and armed with a gun.   

    >>

    SPANAWAY, Washington (AP) - Pierce County sheriff's detectives are investigating the fatal shooting of an armed domestic violence suspect by sheriff's deputies.  KIRO-TV reports the shooting occurred Saturday night in Spanaway, south of Tacoma.  Deputies responded to a 911 call just before 9:30 p.m. from a woman reporting domestic violence. She said her boyfriend was intoxicated and armed with a gun.   

    >>