Help me Hayley: Woman devastated after getting engagement ring b - Spokane, North Idaho News & Weather KHQ.com

Help me Hayley: Woman devastated after getting engagement ring back from Spokane jeweler

Posted: Updated:
In addition to Jennifer receiving a new stone, Kay also refunded her warranty. In addition to Jennifer receiving a new stone, Kay also refunded her warranty.
SPOKANE, Wash. -

A local wife and mother has spent the past few weeks devastated after she said her original diamond engagement ring changed dramatically after being re-plated. It suddenly had black spots she said weren't there before. When the jeweler wasn't cooperative …she said "Help Me Hayley" to get the spot problem cleared up.

"It was beautiful," said Jennifer Barratt.

The ring was a symbol of love, commitment, and a future of happiness. The diamond that once gave Jennifer butterflies, was filling her stomach with knots.

"I know this ring," she said. "I look at it all the time. I noticed instantly this is not right."

Jennifer took her engagement ring into Kay Jewelers back in May to be re-plated. As soon as she got it back, she said she knew it wasn't right. Black spots are clearly visible inside the stone. It was an imperfection that wasn't noted in the paperwork when her husband bought it.

"I thought it looked kind of funny," she said. "I walked around the mall for a little bit and went back and asked them because there were black spots that weren't there before."

She claims this was the jeweler's response…

"She said it was just clean so now you can see those," she said. "They weren't there before."

Jennifer wasn't letting it go.

"I told them I was contacting you and BBB and suddenly they want to work with me," she said.

The local Kay jeweler referred Jennifer to a national customer service agent. The agent talked to Jennifer on the phone and invited her to see other stones. She said Hayley Guenthner would be tagging along. Kay followed up with this email, reading in part:   

"We have transferred in 3 different stones for you to view at that time. Each of these stones would be a better quality grade than what you originally purchased. At this time we will be offering the diamond you choose out of the 3, as a replacement for no additional charge."

"They would not help me before I contacted you," she said. "Now it's a totally different tune."

Hayley and Jennifer went to examine the diamonds together. Jennifer came out happy.

"I think it went well," she said. "They made it right."

In addition to Jennifer receiving a new stone, Kay also refunded her warranty. We reached out to them for comment. This was their response:

"We take customer concerns very seriously and view even one issue as unacceptable. We have reviewed this guest issue, and are pleased to share that we have worked with the guest to confirm a satisfactory resolution. "

When Hayley asked Kay to explain how this happened, they responded, "please feel free to use the previously provided statement as our response on this matter."

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • US Army Officer from Spokane killed in helicopter crash in Iraq

    US Army Officer from Spokane killed in helicopter crash in Iraq

    Tuesday, August 21 2018 1:14 PM EDT2018-08-21 17:14:50 GMT

    SPOKANE, Wash. - The Department of Defense identified the man who died in a helicopter crash in Iraq as 34-year-old Taylor Galvin from Spokane. The DOD says Chief Warrant Officer 3 Taylor J. Galvin died as a result of injuries sustained when his helicopter crash in Sinjar, Ninevah Province, Iraq on Monday. The crash is still under investigation. 

    >>

    SPOKANE, Wash. - The Department of Defense identified the man who died in a helicopter crash in Iraq as 34-year-old Taylor Galvin from Spokane. The DOD says Chief Warrant Officer 3 Taylor J. Galvin died as a result of injuries sustained when his helicopter crash in Sinjar, Ninevah Province, Iraq on Monday. The crash is still under investigation. 

    >>
  • One killed, neighbors lose everything in Spokane Valley condo fire

    One killed, neighbors lose everything in Spokane Valley condo fire

    Tuesday, August 21 2018 2:10 AM EDT2018-08-21 06:10:55 GMT

    SPOKANE VALLEY, Wash.- Spokane Valley firefighters say a condo fire that happened Sunday night killed one person and destroyed at least nine units at the Central Park Condominiums off of 6th Avenue. Billowing smoke and flames was all anyone could see. "It's hard and it all happened so sudden. Within two minutes, everything gets taken away from you. 

    >>

    SPOKANE VALLEY, Wash.- Spokane Valley firefighters say a condo fire that happened Sunday night killed one person and destroyed at least nine units at the Central Park Condominiums off of 6th Avenue. Billowing smoke and flames was all anyone could see. "It's hard and it all happened so sudden. Within two minutes, everything gets taken away from you. 

    >>
  • DEVELOPING: Hammer Kills Woman In N. Idaho; 3 Others Hurt

    DEVELOPING: Hammer Kills Woman In N. Idaho; 3 Others Hurt

    BAYVIEW, Idaho - A woman is dead and two others remain in serious condition after a man armed with a hammer attacked their family in their Bayview home Sunday afternoon.>>
    BAYVIEW, Idaho - A woman is dead and two others remain in serious condition after a man armed with a hammer attacked their family in their Bayview home Sunday afternoon.>>
HD DOPPLER 6i
/
  • Top Stories from KHQHomeMore>>

  • Plane blows 2 tires while taking off from New Jersey airport

    Plane blows 2 tires while taking off from New Jersey airport

    Tuesday, August 21 2018 1:32 PM EDT2018-08-21 17:32:43 GMT

    TETERBORO, N.J. - Authorities say a plane that blew two tires during takeoff at a small New Jersey airport will attempt to make an emergency landing at an airport in Massachusetts. The Gulfstream IV jet was carrying 16 passengers when it left Teterboro Airport around 10:50 a.m. Tuesday. The pilot soon realized what had happened and began circling the airport for about 30 minutes before the jet was diverted. 

    >>

    TETERBORO, N.J. - Authorities say a plane that blew two tires during takeoff at a small New Jersey airport will attempt to make an emergency landing at an airport in Massachusetts. The Gulfstream IV jet was carrying 16 passengers when it left Teterboro Airport around 10:50 a.m. Tuesday. The pilot soon realized what had happened and began circling the airport for about 30 minutes before the jet was diverted. 

    >>
  • US Army Officer from Spokane killed in helicopter crash in Iraq

    US Army Officer from Spokane killed in helicopter crash in Iraq

    Tuesday, August 21 2018 1:14 PM EDT2018-08-21 17:14:50 GMT

    SPOKANE, Wash. - The Department of Defense identified the man who died in a helicopter crash in Iraq as 34-year-old Taylor Galvin from Spokane. The DOD says Chief Warrant Officer 3 Taylor J. Galvin died as a result of injuries sustained when his helicopter crash in Sinjar, Ninevah Province, Iraq on Monday. The crash is still under investigation. 

    >>

    SPOKANE, Wash. - The Department of Defense identified the man who died in a helicopter crash in Iraq as 34-year-old Taylor Galvin from Spokane. The DOD says Chief Warrant Officer 3 Taylor J. Galvin died as a result of injuries sustained when his helicopter crash in Sinjar, Ninevah Province, Iraq on Monday. The crash is still under investigation. 

    >>
  • Fish heads dumped near Alaska school attracts bears

    Fish heads dumped near Alaska school attracts bears

    Tuesday, August 21 2018 1:13 PM EDT2018-08-21 17:13:52 GMT

    Anchorage police are looking for a man who dumped fish heads in woods near an elementary school.    The perpetrator won't have to clean up. A grizzly bear took care of that.    The fish dumper, however, faces a $300 fine for discarding garbage that attracts animals.    Alaska families regularly catch dozens of salmon and are urged to properly dispose of fish parts in fast-moving rivers, ocean waters or regular garbage disposal. 

    >>

    Anchorage police are looking for a man who dumped fish heads in woods near an elementary school.    The perpetrator won't have to clean up. A grizzly bear took care of that.    The fish dumper, however, faces a $300 fine for discarding garbage that attracts animals.    Alaska families regularly catch dozens of salmon and are urged to properly dispose of fish parts in fast-moving rivers, ocean waters or regular garbage disposal. 

    >>