Now on high court, the real Neil Gorsuch set to stand up - Spokane, North Idaho News & Weather KHQ.com

Now on high court, the real Neil Gorsuch set to stand up

Posted: Updated:
WASHINGTON -

Somewhere between the Republican caricature of the next justice of the Supreme Court as a folksy family guy and the Democrats' demonization of him as a cold-hearted automaton, stands Neil Gorsuch.

Largely unknown six months ago, Gorsuch has seen his life story, personality and professional career explored in excruciating detail since he was nominated by President Donald Trump 10 weeks ago.

The portrait that emerges is more nuanced than the extremes drawn by his supporters and critics.

Gorsuch is widely regarded as a warm and collegial family man, boss and jurist, loyal to his employees and kind to those of differing viewpoints. He also has been shown to be a judge who takes such a "rigidly neutral" approach to the law that it can lead to dispassionate rulings with sometimes brutal results.

Four times during his confirmation hearings, Gorsuch invoked a "breakfast table" analogy, telling senators that good judges set aside what they have to eat — and their personal views — before they leave the house in the morning to apply the law and nothing else to the facts of the cases at hand. It was all part of Gorsuch's artful effort to reveal as little as possible of his own opinions.

"We're all human beings," Gorsuch told senators, "but the judge's job is to put that stuff aside and approach the law as you find it."

That ability to compartmentalize, combined with Gorsuch's studious refusal to signal his thinking on contentious issues, left Democrats frustrated. For all his many visits with senators and his hours in the witness seat, Gorsuch had not revealed his core beliefs and may have, according to Democrats, a bias favoring powerful interests over ordinary people.

The question for Sen. Dick Durbin, D-Ill., was "whether there's a beating heart and an independent streak" behind Gorsuch's silver hair and smooth delivery.

Republicans saw Gorsuch's disciplined and detached approach as evidence of the fair and independent mindset that the U.S. needs on its highest court.

Preparing to take the oath of office Monday after a rancorous 54-45 vote in the Senate, Gorsuch soon will largely recede into the cloistered halls of the Supreme Court. He won't vanish entirely; other justices have written books, done speaking tours and interviews.

But Gorsuch won't again face this kind of grilling, into everything from his views on abortion to the avid outdoorsman's favorite fishing holes. (He largely pleaded the Fifth on both.)

The 49-year-old judge was happy to reminisce about his years as a student and lawyer before becoming a federal appellate judge in Denver 10 years ago. He relied on self-deprecating humor and a goodness-gosh-golly demeanor in outsize doses as he deflected the questions he didn't want to answer.

"I might be a little corny," he said at one point to the Senate Judiciary Committee.

"Oh, now we're talking," Gorsuch enthused when the talk turned to fly fishing. "You can't focus on the worries of the world when you're only worried about a trout."

Gorsuch's impressive scholarly and legal credentials were on full display: Columbia, Harvard and Oxford, the latter with scenes that Gorsuch recalled were straight out of a Harry Potter movie.

But Gorsuch, known for the clarity of his legal writings, traced the roots of his success back to an even earlier source, Sister Mary Rose Margaret, the nun of whom he says: "She taught me how to read and she taught me how to diagram a sentence."

Gorsuch, whose mother was a state legislator and then director of the Environmental Protection Agency under President Ronald Reagan, tried to play down the political elements in his background. Gorsuch stressed that when issues such as torture arose during his time in President George W. Bush's Justice Department, he acted not as a policymaker but as a "speechwriter" or "a lawyer for a client."

He did acknowledge, though, that an email he sent criticizing lawyers at big firms for representing detainees being held by the U.S. military at Guantanamo Bay in Cuba was "not my finest hour."

Perhaps no ruling got more attention over the past 10 weeks than a case in which Gorsuch came down against a truck driver who was fired for leaving his trailer of meat on the side of an Illinois road after breaking down on a frigid night in 2009 and fearing he would freeze to death. Asked whether the man's firing wasn't absurd, Gorsuch said simply: "My heart goes out to him. It's just not my job."

For all that he shared, Gorsuch did his best not to telegraph where he might land on a range of topics that he could confront early in his time as a justice, even though both sides think they have a pretty good idea how he would rule.

Cases about voting rights, gun control, religious rights, housing discrimination and immigration are pending before the court. The dispute over Trump's proposed ban on visitors from six majority Muslim countries could be on the way as well.

Gorsuch was careful not to offer any hints on these issues in his exchanges with committee Democrats and Republicans.

Questioned about his views on the Roe v. Wade decision that established a woman's right to have an abortion, Gorsuch would go no further than to voice his respect for legal precedent and say "no one is looking to return us to horse and buggy days."

Sen. Mazie Hirono, D-Hawaii, spoke for many in her party when, nearing the end of two days of testimony, she told Gorsuch: "It remains to be seen whether you will be a justice for all or a justice for some."

(Copyright 2017 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.)

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Doctor accused of spiking pregnant girlfriend's drink with abortion pill

    Doctor accused of spiking pregnant girlfriend's drink with abortion pill

    Friday, December 15 2017 2:22 AM EST2017-12-15 07:22:19 GMT

    ROCHESTER, N.Y. - A doctor is accused of spiking his girlfriend's drink with an abortion pill.  Brooke Fiske told News 8 WROC in Rochester that she and Sikander Imran had been dating on and off for three years when she learned she was pregnant.  Fiske says he didn't want to have the baby so Imran tried talking her into having an abortion, but it wasn't something she wanted.  According to WROC, Imran had recently moved from New York to 

    >>

    ROCHESTER, N.Y. - A doctor is accused of spiking his girlfriend's drink with an abortion pill.  Brooke Fiske told News 8 WROC in Rochester that she and Sikander Imran had been dating on and off for three years when she learned she was pregnant.  Fiske says he didn't want to have the baby so Imran tried talking her into having an abortion, but it wasn't something she wanted.  According to WROC, Imran had recently moved from New York to 

    >>
  • Deputies confirm missing Spokane woman in remote area of Shoshone County found safe

    Deputies confirm missing Spokane woman in remote area of Shoshone County found safe

    Thursday, December 14 2017 7:27 PM EST2017-12-15 00:27:17 GMT

    SHOSHONE COUNTY, Idaho - The Shoshone County Sheriff's Office and Idaho State Police are actively searching for a missing Spokane woman north of Kingston near Coeur d'Alene River Road.  Undersheriff Holly Lindsey tells us that this all started Wednesday night when three girls, two of them teenagers and one in her 20's, went north to watch the meteor shower. 

    >>

    SHOSHONE COUNTY, Idaho - The Shoshone County Sheriff's Office and Idaho State Police are actively searching for a missing Spokane woman north of Kingston near Coeur d'Alene River Road.  Undersheriff Holly Lindsey tells us that this all started Wednesday night when three girls, two of them teenagers and one in her 20's, went north to watch the meteor shower. 

    >>
  • See a movie in a theater every day for a year for only $90? Costco offering bundle with MoviePass and Fandor

    See a movie in a theater every day for a year for only $90? Costco offering bundle with MoviePass and Fandor

    Wednesday, December 13 2017 5:35 PM EST2017-12-13 22:35:41 GMT

    KHQ.COM - If you're into watching movies in theaters AND at home, Costco has a deal for you! The wholesaler is offering an evoucher that bundles a full year of access to MoviePass and Fandor for only $89.99.  MoviePass, which gives free movie tickets, usually costs $120 a year alone. Twelve months of Fandor, a movie streaming service, is $60. 

    >>

    KHQ.COM - If you're into watching movies in theaters AND at home, Costco has a deal for you! The wholesaler is offering an evoucher that bundles a full year of access to MoviePass and Fandor for only $89.99.  MoviePass, which gives free movie tickets, usually costs $120 a year alone. Twelve months of Fandor, a movie streaming service, is $60. 

    >>
HD DOPPLER 6i
/
  • Top Stories from KHQHomeMore>>

  • Eighth planet found in faraway solar system, matching ours

    Eighth planet found in faraway solar system, matching ours

    Friday, December 15 2017 11:38 PM EST2017-12-16 04:38:05 GMT
    NASA/Ames Research Center/Wendy StenzelNASA/Ames Research Center/Wendy Stenzel

    CAPE CANAVERAL, Fla. (AP) - An eighth planet has been found in a faraway solar system, matching our own in numbers. Even more amazing, machines and not humans made the discovery. NASA joined with Google on Thursday to announce the finding. This eighth planet orbits the star known as Kepler-90, 2,545 light-years away. Like Earth, this new planet is the third rock from its sun. But it's much closer to its sun and therefore a scorching 800 degrees Fahrenheit (427 Celsius) 

    >>

    CAPE CANAVERAL, Fla. (AP) - An eighth planet has been found in a faraway solar system, matching our own in numbers. Even more amazing, machines and not humans made the discovery. NASA joined with Google on Thursday to announce the finding. This eighth planet orbits the star known as Kepler-90, 2,545 light-years away. Like Earth, this new planet is the third rock from its sun. But it's much closer to its sun and therefore a scorching 800 degrees Fahrenheit (427 Celsius) 

    >>
  • ‘Criminal Santa’ calls 911 for help after getting trapped in California chimney

    ‘Criminal Santa’ calls 911 for help after getting trapped in California chimney

    Friday, December 15 2017 11:30 PM EST2017-12-16 04:30:23 GMT
    Citrus Heights PoliceCitrus Heights Police

    CITRUS HEIGHTS, Calif. - A burglary suspect was arrested after becoming lodged in a chimney while trying to break into a business and then calling 911 for help, the Citrus Heights Police Department said Friday. Police said 32-year-old Jesse Berube slid down the chimney of a business in the 6900 block of Greenback Lane, trying to break in, but instead got stuck.  According to KCRA News, Berube was able to move enough to reach his phone and call 911.

    >>

    CITRUS HEIGHTS, Calif. - A burglary suspect was arrested after becoming lodged in a chimney while trying to break into a business and then calling 911 for help, the Citrus Heights Police Department said Friday. Police said 32-year-old Jesse Berube slid down the chimney of a business in the 6900 block of Greenback Lane, trying to break in, but instead got stuck.  According to KCRA News, Berube was able to move enough to reach his phone and call 911.

    >>
  • KCSO Deputy takes pies in the face to help local boy fight cancer

    KCSO Deputy takes pies in the face to help local boy fight cancer

    Friday, December 15 2017 9:53 PM EST2017-12-16 02:53:35 GMT
    The Kootenai County Sheriff’s Office is throwing its support behind an effort to help a local family whose young son is undergoing treatment for cancer. Deputy Doug Goodman, a School Resource Officer, joined students and staff at Dalton Elementary School on Friday morning for the school’s annual Christmas sing-along. During the morning assembly, the kids cheered on a “pie in the face” activity. Deputy Goodman took four pies to the face in recognition of a...>>
    The Kootenai County Sheriff’s Office is throwing its support behind an effort to help a local family whose young son is undergoing treatment for cancer. Deputy Doug Goodman, a School Resource Officer, joined students and staff at Dalton Elementary School on Friday morning for the school’s annual Christmas sing-along. During the morning assembly, the kids cheered on a “pie in the face” activity. Deputy Goodman took four pies to the face in recognition of a...>>