Jury deliberates after toddler homicide trial's closing argument - Spokane, North Idaho News & Weather KHQ.com

Jury deliberates after toddler homicide trial's closing arguments

Posted: Updated:
Judge Cooney giving the jury their instructions for their deliberations Judge Cooney giving the jury their instructions for their deliberations
SPOKANE, Wash. -

A jury is currently deliberating whether the man who’s accused of beating and killing a 2-year-old girl did it.

This all began in September, after deputies were called out to a home on the South Hill where Adalynn Hoyt was found dead. Prosecutors say she was left in the care of Jason Obermiller the night before, but when she was found, he wasn’t at the house. In fact, they say that after he found out that Adalynn was dead, no one could reach him after that.

Prosecutors argued that Obermiller hurt Adalynn to get back at her mother and his ex, Lovina Rainey. They say he was upset because he was stuck with a drug debt he believed wasn’t his to pay.

During the trial, a medical examiner testified to the fact that there were more than 60 points of impact on the Adalynn’s 2-year-old body.

“She was hit so hard that she could neither swallow nor inhale that little bit of pizza that was stuck to the palate of her mouth,” said Gayle Ervin, Spokane County deputy prosecutor, during her closing argument.

The defense on the other hand told the jury they should have doubts about the truth of the charge of second-degree murder. They reiterated how much Obermiller cared for Adalynn, but also pointed to the fact that there were other people in the house after Obermiller had left shortly before midnight. They also suggested that certain witnesses lied to detectives in their statements.

“It is much more likely that Adalynn Hoyt was killed by Lovina Rainey or Anthony Bettcher sometime after 6:30 a.m.,” said Kevin Griffen, Obermiller’s attorney.

While a lot has been argued during this trial, there is one piece of testimony that hasn’t been disputed.

“That little girl is never going to sit up and look at her and say mommy,” Ervin said.

As soon as the jury delivers its verdict, we will bring you that information. 

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • New York State illegally moving convicted sex offenders from prisons into group homes with the developmentally disabled

    New York State illegally moving convicted sex offenders from prisons into group homes with the developmentally disabled

    Thursday, September 20 2018 9:14 AM EDT2018-09-20 13:14:31 GMT
    Three State agencies are involved in placing convicted sex offenders in group homes or hiding this information from the families and the general public>>
    Three State agencies are involved in placing convicted sex offenders in group homes or hiding this information from the families and the general public>>
  • Neighbors concerned by abnormal activity at Hays Park in north Spokane

    Neighbors concerned by abnormal activity at Hays Park in north Spokane

    Wednesday, September 26 2018 4:52 AM EDT2018-09-26 08:52:20 GMT

    An ongoing, series of issues at Hays Park is making several residents worried about their safety. "I've been threatened to be shot, to be stabbed, to have my head crushed in, to have my dogs head crushed in," Jon Nolend, a resident living by the park, said. Nolend and his wife, Quinn Rapp, said they're both witnesses and victims to daily disturbances involving narcotics, property crime and harassment. Some instances have resulted in physical confrontations, according to No...

    >>

    An ongoing, series of issues at Hays Park is making several residents worried about their safety. "I've been threatened to be shot, to be stabbed, to have my head crushed in, to have my dogs head crushed in," Jon Nolend, a resident living by the park, said. Nolend and his wife, Quinn Rapp, said they're both witnesses and victims to daily disturbances involving narcotics, property crime and harassment. Some instances have resulted in physical confrontations, according to No...

    >>
  • Good Samaritan uses tourniquet to help save hit-and-run victim in north Spokane

    Good Samaritan uses tourniquet to help save hit-and-run victim in north Spokane

    Wednesday, September 26 2018 2:31 AM EDT2018-09-26 06:31:33 GMT

    SPOKANE, Wash. - A Spokane security guard never thought he'd have to use a tourniquet, but he still carries it with him just about everywhere he goes. "You never know when you're going to come across something where you could be the guy to help because you know what to do," said John Roach. " I wanted to help the guy and I was able to." Roach was driving on Market Street in north Spokane when he came across the aftermath of a hit-and-run. 

    >>

    SPOKANE, Wash. - A Spokane security guard never thought he'd have to use a tourniquet, but he still carries it with him just about everywhere he goes. "You never know when you're going to come across something where you could be the guy to help because you know what to do," said John Roach. " I wanted to help the guy and I was able to." Roach was driving on Market Street in north Spokane when he came across the aftermath of a hit-and-run. 

    >>
HD DOPPLER 6i
/
  • Top Stories from KHQHomeMore>>

  • Critters begin crossing animals-only bridge over I-90

    Critters begin crossing animals-only bridge over I-90

    Wednesday, September 26 2018 8:21 AM EDT2018-09-26 12:21:01 GMT

    SEATTLE - Deer have started using an unfinished wildlife bridge over Interstate 90 east of Snoqualmie Pass. The Northwest News Network reports the Washington State Department of Transportation on Monday celebrated the opening of a section of widened freeway there. The overcrossing is expected to reduce animal-vehicle collisions.  

    >>

    SEATTLE - Deer have started using an unfinished wildlife bridge over Interstate 90 east of Snoqualmie Pass. The Northwest News Network reports the Washington State Department of Transportation on Monday celebrated the opening of a section of widened freeway there. The overcrossing is expected to reduce animal-vehicle collisions.  

    >>
  • Neighbors concerned by abnormal activity at Hays Park in north Spokane

    Neighbors concerned by abnormal activity at Hays Park in north Spokane

    Wednesday, September 26 2018 4:52 AM EDT2018-09-26 08:52:20 GMT

    An ongoing, series of issues at Hays Park is making several residents worried about their safety. "I've been threatened to be shot, to be stabbed, to have my head crushed in, to have my dogs head crushed in," Jon Nolend, a resident living by the park, said. Nolend and his wife, Quinn Rapp, said they're both witnesses and victims to daily disturbances involving narcotics, property crime and harassment. Some instances have resulted in physical confrontations, according to No...

    >>

    An ongoing, series of issues at Hays Park is making several residents worried about their safety. "I've been threatened to be shot, to be stabbed, to have my head crushed in, to have my dogs head crushed in," Jon Nolend, a resident living by the park, said. Nolend and his wife, Quinn Rapp, said they're both witnesses and victims to daily disturbances involving narcotics, property crime and harassment. Some instances have resulted in physical confrontations, according to No...

    >>
  • Good Samaritan uses tourniquet to help save hit-and-run victim in north Spokane

    Good Samaritan uses tourniquet to help save hit-and-run victim in north Spokane

    Wednesday, September 26 2018 2:31 AM EDT2018-09-26 06:31:33 GMT

    SPOKANE, Wash. - A Spokane security guard never thought he'd have to use a tourniquet, but he still carries it with him just about everywhere he goes. "You never know when you're going to come across something where you could be the guy to help because you know what to do," said John Roach. " I wanted to help the guy and I was able to." Roach was driving on Market Street in north Spokane when he came across the aftermath of a hit-and-run. 

    >>

    SPOKANE, Wash. - A Spokane security guard never thought he'd have to use a tourniquet, but he still carries it with him just about everywhere he goes. "You never know when you're going to come across something where you could be the guy to help because you know what to do," said John Roach. " I wanted to help the guy and I was able to." Roach was driving on Market Street in north Spokane when he came across the aftermath of a hit-and-run. 

    >>