Are automatic traffic enforcement cameras unconstitutional? - Spokane, North Idaho News & Weather KHQ.com

Are automatic traffic enforcement cameras unconstitutional?

Posted: Updated:

KHQ.COM - Rarely do simple misdemeanors ever make it to the supreme court,let along speeding tickets. But today for the first time ever, Iowa Supreme Court Justices heard a case from a woman who says automatic traffic enforcement systems are unconstitutional. Marla Leaf claims she was wrongfully ticketed by one of the traffic cameras back in February of 2015.

Leaf received a $75 traffic ticket in the mail stating she was clocked by an automatic speed camera driving 68 in a 55 on a highway in Cedar Rapids, Iowa.

Most people would have just paid the ticket and moved on but not Leaf; she's decided to fight it, saying it's about the principle. Leaf claims there's no way she's was going 68. She and her husband claim that it was really icy and that if she had been driving that fast, her mustang would have ended up in the ditch.

Leaf is part of a growing number of people who believe automatic traffic enforcement system are unfair and in some cases unconstitutional. That is what her lawyer James Larew presented Thursday to the Iowa Supreme Court.

Larew asked the court to consider 3 points:

1.) Does this ordinance infringe on a fundamental right to travel?

2.) Does the manner in which these traffic violations are processed violate due process rights?

3.) Does the private company that operates these cameras police power unlawfully?

Across the state of Iowa, many of these camera have already been shut off or taken down. As for leaf, she says she will continue to stand firm in what she believes in.

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • You’re Not Alone: Death of 13-year-old girl shocks Moses Lake community

    You’re Not Alone: Death of 13-year-old girl shocks Moses Lake community

    Tuesday, June 19 2018 9:43 PM EDT2018-06-20 01:43:35 GMT

    MOSES LAKE, Wash. - Blue balloons soared into the open skies of Moses Lake Tuesday afternoon; each one was inked with a message to Valerie Bashaw, the 13-year-old girl who recently took her own life. “We know she’s not physically here but in our hearts and minds and souls,” said one of Bashaw’s ballet instructors, Rian Miles. 

    >>

    MOSES LAKE, Wash. - Blue balloons soared into the open skies of Moses Lake Tuesday afternoon; each one was inked with a message to Valerie Bashaw, the 13-year-old girl who recently took her own life. “We know she’s not physically here but in our hearts and minds and souls,” said one of Bashaw’s ballet instructors, Rian Miles. 

    >>
  • Spokane family forced to move after racist threats left on their door

    Spokane family forced to move after racist threats left on their door

    Wednesday, June 20 2018 2:18 AM EDT2018-06-20 06:18:49 GMT

    SPOKANE, Wash. - It's been an incredibly difficult couple of months for Kaley Hilderbrand and her family. "We're in the middle of moving from an apartment to a house," Hilderbrand said.  It's not something the mom of a brand new baby girl though she would be doing. Back in April, the soon-to-be-married mother of three was living in a north Spokane apartment complex when she received an angry letter about doing laundry at night.

    >>

    SPOKANE, Wash. - It's been an incredibly difficult couple of months for Kaley Hilderbrand and her family. "We're in the middle of moving from an apartment to a house," Hilderbrand said.  It's not something the mom of a brand new baby girl though she would be doing. Back in April, the soon-to-be-married mother of three was living in a north Spokane apartment complex when she received an angry letter about doing laundry at night.

    >>
  • VIDEO: Parents, fans brawl during youth softball tournament

    VIDEO: Parents, fans brawl during youth softball tournament

    Tuesday, June 19 2018 5:21 PM EDT2018-06-19 21:21:41 GMT

    KINGSPORT, Tenn. (AP) - Video shows a brawl that broke out between parents and fans of two North Carolina girls softball teams at a Tennessee park.    The Kingsport Times-News reports the fight happened Saturday in Kingsport during a 12-and-under tournament sponsored by USA Softball.    Todd McLemore with Kingsport's Parks and Recreation Department says a verbal confrontation between two sets of spectators escalated into a chaotic brawl after someone got pushed.

    >>

    KINGSPORT, Tenn. (AP) - Video shows a brawl that broke out between parents and fans of two North Carolina girls softball teams at a Tennessee park.    The Kingsport Times-News reports the fight happened Saturday in Kingsport during a 12-and-under tournament sponsored by USA Softball.    Todd McLemore with Kingsport's Parks and Recreation Department says a verbal confrontation between two sets of spectators escalated into a chaotic brawl after someone got pushed.

    >>
HD DOPPLER 6i
/
  • Top Stories from KHQHomeMore>>

  • Philadelphia Zoo welcomes baby giraffe named Beau

    Philadelphia Zoo welcomes baby giraffe named Beau

    Wednesday, June 20 2018 12:33 PM EDT2018-06-20 16:33:21 GMT
    The Philadelphia Zoo has welcomed a baby giraffe .    Zoo officials announced Tuesday that Beau was born June 10 to parents Stella and Gus. Beau stands 5-foot-7-inches and weighs an estimated 125 pounds.    Beau has a 7-year-old sister Abigail. The four are the only giraffes at the zoo.    Zoo officials say Beau will be separated from his father, Gus, for a lengthy period of time, as male giraffes do not care for newborns.    Both Beau and his m...>>
    The Philadelphia Zoo has welcomed a baby giraffe .    Zoo officials announced Tuesday that Beau was born June 10 to parents Stella and Gus. Beau stands 5-foot-7-inches and weighs an estimated 125 pounds.    Beau has a 7-year-old sister Abigail. The four are the only giraffes at the zoo.    Zoo officials say Beau will be separated from his father, Gus, for a lengthy period of time, as male giraffes do not care for newborns.    Both Beau and his m...>>
  • Homeland Security drafts plan to end family separation; Trump to sign 'something'

    Homeland Security drafts plan to end family separation; Trump to sign 'something'

    Wednesday, June 20 2018 12:18 PM EDT2018-06-20 16:18:46 GMT

    WASHINGTON - President Donald Trump says he'll be signing something "in a little while" to address the spike in the number of migrant children being separated from their families at the border. Trump said during a White House meeting with members of Congress that, "We want to keep families together." 

    >>

    WASHINGTON - President Donald Trump says he'll be signing something "in a little while" to address the spike in the number of migrant children being separated from their families at the border. Trump said during a White House meeting with members of Congress that, "We want to keep families together." 

    >>
  • Nickelodeon, HQ Trivia mark 'Double Dare' reboot's debut

    Nickelodeon, HQ Trivia mark 'Double Dare' reboot's debut

    Wednesday, June 20 2018 12:09 PM EDT2018-06-20 16:09:04 GMT

    LOS ANGELES - Nickelodeon is joining with HQ Trivia to celebrate the "Double Dare" reboot.  A 1990s-themed trivia game will pair the Nickelodeon show's original host, Marc Summers, with HQ host Scott Rogowsky. The game will include "Double Dare" trivia questions and moments familiar to fans of the 1986 to 1993 series, including physical challenges and toss-ups. 

    >>

    LOS ANGELES - Nickelodeon is joining with HQ Trivia to celebrate the "Double Dare" reboot.  A 1990s-themed trivia game will pair the Nickelodeon show's original host, Marc Summers, with HQ host Scott Rogowsky. The game will include "Double Dare" trivia questions and moments familiar to fans of the 1986 to 1993 series, including physical challenges and toss-ups. 

    >>