AP FACT CHECK: Lawmakers off mark on public records facts - Spokane, North Idaho News & Weather KHQ.com

AP FACT CHECK: Lawmakers off mark on public records facts

Posted: Updated:
OLYMPIA, Wash. -

Washington lawmakers are facing a public backlash after they bypassed normal legislative procedures and quickly approved a bill exempting themselves from the state's Public Records Act and subjecting themselves instead to more limited disclosure requirements.
  
More than a dozen newspapers across the state ran front-page editorials Tuesday urging Gov. Jay Inslee to veto the measure that was passed by the Legislature on a "veto-proof" two-thirds margin Friday - a 41-9 vote in the Senate and a 83-14 vote in the House - and force lawmakers to decide whether they want to take a second vote to override his action.
  
The bipartisan bill prohibits the release of lawmaker communication with constituents, but allows release of some lawmaker correspondence beginning on July 1, including those with lobbyists; information from lawmaker calendars; and final disciplinary reports. However, because the bill is retroactive, it would prohibit the release of the records being sought by the coalition of news organizations that sued last September and who prevailed in an initial court ruling last month.
  
In defending their votes, state legislators have made several assertions - on social media, their websites and in letters to their constituents - about the bill, which was introduced and passed in less than 48 hours.
  
___
  
CLAIM: Democratic Sen. Jamie Pedersen writes for an online labor publication that it's clear that lawmakers are exempt from the state's Public Records Act, passed in 1972: "This ruling overturns settled law from the last 45 years."
  
THE FACTS: The law is not settled.  A coalition of media groups, led by The Associated Press, sued last year. In denying media requests for lawmaker records in recent years, the Legislature often cited a 1995 change in law that retroactively defined what a legislative record was. Attorneys for the Legislature later argued in court that changes in 2007, when some of the public records act's definitions were incorporated into a state statute separate from the campaign finance portions of the original initiative, definitively removed lawmakers from disclosure requirements.
  
At one point during a December court hearing, the judge asked Paul Lawrence, one of the four private attorneys hired by the Legislature, if lawmakers were subject to the public records act between 1995 and 2007.
  
"I think it's an open question," Lawrence acknowledged.
  
Last month, Thurston County Superior Court Judge Chris Lanese ruled state representatives and senators and their offices are fully subject to the same broad public disclosure requirements that cover other local and state elected officials and employees at state agencies.
  
___
  
CLAIM: Democratic Rep. Gael Tarleton says the Legislature should be treated the same as the judiciary, which is exempt from the Public records Act. She wrote on her legislative website: "Just like the judicial branch, the Legislature - following two decades of legal advice from both Republican and Democratic Attorneys General - believed it was also not subject to disclosure requirements under the Public Records Act, which precipitated the media lawsuit against the state Legislature."
  
THE FACTS: Yes, the judiciary is exempt. A 7-2 Supreme Court ruling in 2009 held that the judiciary is exempt from the Public Records Act. In 2016, the court enacted an administrative rule - after public meetings and input - relating to which court records are exempt and which are disclosable. The only judicial review thus far on the Legislature's assertion of exemption is the Thurston County ruling last month, in which the judge, citing the judiciary comparison, wrote that when relating to individual lawmakers, "this argument may be disposed of in short order." While the superior court judge ruled that the law is ambiguous when it comes to the entities of the Senate and House as a whole, he wrote the offices of individual lawmakers clearly fall under the definition of state offices considered to be agencies under the law and thus subject to broader disclosure requirements.
  
___
  
CLAIM: Democratic Rep. Noel Frame said the privacy of constituents needs to be protected. She wrote on her Facebook page that lawmakers "have an obligation to protect the privacy of our constituents and the broader public. And we have to balance that against the public interest in transparency of our government."
  
THE FACTS: There are already provisions to protect constituency privacy in certain cases as people already communicate with local elected officials and employees at state agencies about sensitive information that state lawmakers are expressing concern about. The current Public Records Act already allows a privacy exemption in cases where the information "would be highly offensive to a reasonable person, and "is not of legitimate concern to the public." There are also more than 500 exemptions to the PRA that could have been used to shield truly confidential information, like social security numbers, bank account numbers, sensitive medical or mental health information.
  
___
  
CLAIM: Lawmakers said an official public hearing could not be held because it was too late in the legislative session, the rushed legislative process was only done because the judge ruled in the middle of the session that is set to end March 8 and refused to stay his decision. Pedersen wrote : "I regret that the bill did not have time to go through the regular committee process. That is driven mostly by the fact that Judge Lanese ruled in the middle of the legislative session and refused to stay his decision. By the time our counsel had drafted the bill and had it ready to introduce, we were already past the time when the bill could have been heard in the regular process."
  
THE FACTS: On the same day that lawmakers passed SB 6617 out of both chambers, they introduced a new bill related to raising the age to purchase certain semi-automatic rifles or shotguns from 18 to 21, and it received an official public hearing Tuesday. As for the concern about the stay, in court, Lanese noted that no records would be released before next steps were to be discussed at a scheduled March 9 status conference. Court filings show that legislative lawyers never asked Lanese for a stay, and an attorney for the media coalition notes they still could if they wished to. However, lawmakers for the Legislature have filed a motion for a stay with the state Supreme Court, which has not yet made a decision on whether to take the case on direct review or to grant the stay.
  
___
  
Find AP Fact Checks at http://apne.ws/2kbx8bd
  
Follow APFactCheck on Twitter: https://twitter.com/APFactCheck

(Copyright 2018 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.)

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • You’re Not Alone: Death of 13-year-old girl shocks Moses Lake community

    You’re Not Alone: Death of 13-year-old girl shocks Moses Lake community

    Tuesday, June 19 2018 9:43 PM EDT2018-06-20 01:43:35 GMT

    MOSES LAKE, Wash. - Blue balloons soared into the open skies of Moses Lake Tuesday afternoon; each one was inked with a message to Valerie Bashaw, the 13-year-old girl who recently took her own life. “We know she’s not physically here but in our hearts and minds and souls,” said one of Bashaw’s ballet instructors, Rian Miles. 

    >>

    MOSES LAKE, Wash. - Blue balloons soared into the open skies of Moses Lake Tuesday afternoon; each one was inked with a message to Valerie Bashaw, the 13-year-old girl who recently took her own life. “We know she’s not physically here but in our hearts and minds and souls,” said one of Bashaw’s ballet instructors, Rian Miles. 

    >>
  • VIDEO: Parents, fans brawl during youth softball tournament

    VIDEO: Parents, fans brawl during youth softball tournament

    Tuesday, June 19 2018 5:21 PM EDT2018-06-19 21:21:41 GMT

    KINGSPORT, Tenn. (AP) - Video shows a brawl that broke out between parents and fans of two North Carolina girls softball teams at a Tennessee park.    The Kingsport Times-News reports the fight happened Saturday in Kingsport during a 12-and-under tournament sponsored by USA Softball.    Todd McLemore with Kingsport's Parks and Recreation Department says a verbal confrontation between two sets of spectators escalated into a chaotic brawl after someone got pushed.

    >>

    KINGSPORT, Tenn. (AP) - Video shows a brawl that broke out between parents and fans of two North Carolina girls softball teams at a Tennessee park.    The Kingsport Times-News reports the fight happened Saturday in Kingsport during a 12-and-under tournament sponsored by USA Softball.    Todd McLemore with Kingsport's Parks and Recreation Department says a verbal confrontation between two sets of spectators escalated into a chaotic brawl after someone got pushed.

    >>
  • Spokane family forced to move after racist threats left on their door

    Spokane family forced to move after racist threats left on their door

    Wednesday, June 20 2018 2:18 AM EDT2018-06-20 06:18:49 GMT

    SPOKANE, Wash. - It's been an incredibly difficult couple of months for Kaley Hilderbrand and her family. "We're in the middle of moving from an apartment to a house," Hilderbrand said.  It's not something the mom of a brand new baby girl though she would be doing. Back in April, the soon-to-be-married mother of three was living in a north Spokane apartment complex when she received an angry letter about doing laundry at night.

    >>

    SPOKANE, Wash. - It's been an incredibly difficult couple of months for Kaley Hilderbrand and her family. "We're in the middle of moving from an apartment to a house," Hilderbrand said.  It's not something the mom of a brand new baby girl though she would be doing. Back in April, the soon-to-be-married mother of three was living in a north Spokane apartment complex when she received an angry letter about doing laundry at night.

    >>
HD DOPPLER 6i
/
  • Top Stories from KHQHomeMore>>

  • WSP: Driver lucky to only receive minor injuries after not wearing seat belt

    WSP: Driver lucky to only receive minor injuries after not wearing seat belt

    Wednesday, June 20 2018 7:55 PM EDT2018-06-20 23:55:54 GMT
    Courtesy: WSP Trooper Brian Moore's twitterCourtesy: WSP Trooper Brian Moore's twitter
    Courtesy: WSP Trooper Brian Moore's twitterCourtesy: WSP Trooper Brian Moore's twitter

    CLE ELUM, Wash. - Buckle up! That's the message from Washington State Patrol. According to troopers, a driver is counting his blessings after he received only minor injuries from a collision without wearing a seat belt.  Washington State Patrol Trooper Brian Moore tweeted picture proof after a driver crashed on Bullfron Road near Cle Elum. Trooper Moore told KIRO 7 that the driver was not wearing a seat belt. Instead, the belt was hanging 

    >>

    CLE ELUM, Wash. - Buckle up! That's the message from Washington State Patrol. According to troopers, a driver is counting his blessings after he received only minor injuries from a collision without wearing a seat belt.  Washington State Patrol Trooper Brian Moore tweeted picture proof after a driver crashed on Bullfron Road near Cle Elum. Trooper Moore told KIRO 7 that the driver was not wearing a seat belt. Instead, the belt was hanging 

    >>
  • Coroner rules death of Wenatchee woman as accidental drowning

    Coroner rules death of Wenatchee woman as accidental drowning

    Wednesday, June 20 2018 7:29 PM EDT2018-06-20 23:29:02 GMT

    COULEE CITY, Wash. - Grant County Coroner Craig Morrison on Tuesday determined that the death of a 43-year-old Wenatchee woman in Park Lake was due to accidental drowning. According to the Grant County Sheriff's Office, Danielle Rea Combs was riding in a vehicle with a companion early Friday morning when they stopped to rest around 3:30 a.m. While her companion slept in the car, Combs apparently walked to the lake’s edge and fell in.

    >>

    COULEE CITY, Wash. - Grant County Coroner Craig Morrison on Tuesday determined that the death of a 43-year-old Wenatchee woman in Park Lake was due to accidental drowning. According to the Grant County Sheriff's Office, Danielle Rea Combs was riding in a vehicle with a companion early Friday morning when they stopped to rest around 3:30 a.m. While her companion slept in the car, Combs apparently walked to the lake’s edge and fell in.

    >>
  • Dust storm on Mars covers entire planet

    Dust storm on Mars covers entire planet

    Wednesday, June 20 2018 7:24 PM EDT2018-06-20 23:24:10 GMT
    Photo: NASAPhoto: NASA

    CAPE CANAVERAL, Fla. (AP) - A dust storm at Mars is now global, keeping NASA's Opportunity rover out of touch with Earth.    Flight controllers lost contact with the rover more than a week ago. At the time, the dust storm covered one-fourth of Mars. NASA said Wednesday the storm now encircles the red planet, with only tall volcano peaks and the poles exposed to the sun.  

    >>

    CAPE CANAVERAL, Fla. (AP) - A dust storm at Mars is now global, keeping NASA's Opportunity rover out of touch with Earth.    Flight controllers lost contact with the rover more than a week ago. At the time, the dust storm covered one-fourth of Mars. NASA said Wednesday the storm now encircles the red planet, with only tall volcano peaks and the poles exposed to the sun.  

    >>