AP Explains: A look at DNA-sharing services and privacy - Spokane, North Idaho News & Weather KHQ.com

AP Explains: A look at DNA-sharing services and privacy

Posted: Updated:
(AP Photo/Rich Pedroncelli) (AP Photo/Rich Pedroncelli)
NEW YORK, NY -

(AP) - The use of a genealogy website to track down a suspected California serial killer illustrates both the extraordinary power of DNA-sharing services and the broad privacy concerns that surround the fast-growing commercial market for genetic analysis.

TV commercials for companies such as 23andMe and Ancestry.com pitch their services as simple and fun ways of learning about family heritage and health. And while those companies on Friday sought to distance themselves from the free GEDmatch website used by police, the California case exposed broader questions about what happens after consumers mail their saliva away for DNA analysis and upload the results to the internet.

"For those of us who were skeptical about turning over our genetic information to corporations, this case proved all of those fears true," said Daniel De Simone, a New Jerseyresearcher whose relatives have used DNA services.

The co-founder of GEDmatch said Friday that he is concerned about privacy after learning that law enforcement used the site and insists that his company does not "hand out data."

"This was done without our knowledge, and it's been overwhelming," Curtis Rogers told The Associated Press.

Authorities have not publicly described details of the methods that led to the arrest of 72-year-old Joseph James DeAngelo, a former police officer. But some other researchers who use GEDmatch for a similar purpose told The Associated Press how it might have been done.

Colleen Fitzpatrick and Margaret Press run the DNA Doe Project, a California-based nonprofit that uses DNA from unidentified bodies to look for relatives and learn the names of the dead. They suspect the authorities used a method similar to their own.

Investigators probably started with the complete DNA code from the killer. Then, after putting the data into a format that GEDmatch can read, they plugged it into the Florida-based site and asked it to look for matches, they said.

The site compares particular segments of genetic material, looking for similarities to other samples in its database. The degree of similarity can indicate how related two people are, finding ties as distant as fifth cousins, Fitzpatrick and Press said.

Once the site has returned a list of matches and degree of similarity, more sleuthing begins.

People in the database may have listed their names or just their emails, which in turn might identify them if they've used the same one on other sites. More information can come from searches of public records, Facebook and especially obituaries, which list parents and other relatives.

Then a researcher can turn to online collections of family trees, like those on Ancestry.com. There, one might uncover many trees that include the apparent relatives found on GEDmatch. That allows the construction of speculative trees that include the mystery person, plus those apparent relatives, in an effort to find overlaps that indicate common ancestors.

If common ancestors appear, lineage can be worked out in detail, up to the present day. Researches look for a spot that contains someone of the right geographic location and age to be the person under investigation.

"It's part art and part science," Press said.

To some, scouring this publicly shared data to track down the so-called Golden State Killer seems like a worthwhile cause. But for others it raises alarms.

De Simone said he has never used a DNA ancestry service.

"What's especially troubling to me is that neither had DeAngelo," he said. He compared the situation to Facebook's data-protection scandal involving Cambridge Analytica because "it's not only users that are caught up in this net, it's also those with relationships to users. In this case, though, it's not just networked relationships, it's actual genetic relationships."

The big commercial databases insist they have much stricter customer privacy practices than websites such as GEDmatch and don't hand over data without a court order.

"As a private platform, we do not allow the comparison of genetic data processed by any third party to genetic profiles within our database. Further, we do not share customer data with any public databases or with entities that may increase the risk of law enforcement access," 23andMe spokesman Andy Kill said in an email.

It's unclear whether the California case will affect customers' trust in DNA services overall.

"These companies are saying that they're different," said Tiffany Li, a technology attorney and Yale Law School fellow. "I think what's key is this open-source database is made up of data profiles that people mostly got from those private companies."

Li said the demand for personal genetic information that helps uncover long-lost relatives and family backgrounds is high enough that this privacy "dust-up" will likely blow over. But, she said, it should serve as a warning for stewards of DNA databases to be more careful and more transparent about how data is used.

"They should at least try to do more to make people aware," Li said. "The terms could be clearer. The companies could also decide to self-regulate before Congress gets to them and create data standards about the DNA they store."

(Copyright 2018 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.)

4/27/2018 3:20:45 PM (GMT -7:00)

  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • New York State illegally moving convicted sex offenders from prisons into group homes with the developmentally disabled

    New York State illegally moving convicted sex offenders from prisons into group homes with the developmentally disabled

    Thursday, September 20 2018 9:14 AM EDT2018-09-20 13:14:31 GMT
    Three State agencies are involved in placing convicted sex offenders in group homes or hiding this information from the families and the general public>>
    Three State agencies are involved in placing convicted sex offenders in group homes or hiding this information from the families and the general public>>
  • Opponents and activists for I-1639 sound off

    Opponents and activists for I-1639 sound off

    Saturday, September 22 2018 9:16 PM EDT2018-09-23 01:16:50 GMT

    SPOKANE, Wash. - Initiative-1639 has been the root of controversy ever since supporters began asking for signatures. It became even more complicated when the Washington Supreme Court overturned a Thurston County judges decision after the judge initially threw out over 300,000 signatures saying the petition didn't follow election law claiming it was unreadable. 

    >>

    SPOKANE, Wash. - Initiative-1639 has been the root of controversy ever since supporters began asking for signatures. It became even more complicated when the Washington Supreme Court overturned a Thurston County judges decision after the judge initially threw out over 300,000 signatures saying the petition didn't follow election law claiming it was unreadable. 

    >>
  • Detectives identify woman found in Spokane River

    Detectives identify woman found in Spokane River

    Thursday, September 20 2018 8:35 PM EDT2018-09-21 00:35:31 GMT

    SPOKANE, Wash. - Update: Detectives have identified the woman found in the Spokane River September 15 just hours after releasing a rending of what she may have looked like. Detectives continue to work to determine what occurred prior to her death.

    >>

    SPOKANE, Wash. - Update: Detectives have identified the woman found in the Spokane River September 15 just hours after releasing a rending of what she may have looked like. Detectives continue to work to determine what occurred prior to her death.

    >>
HD DOPPLER 6i
/
  • Top Stories from KHQHomeMore>>

  • Cold Case: The Missing Wedding Guest

    Cold Case: The Missing Wedding Guest

    Sunday, September 23 2018 11:39 PM EDT2018-09-24 03:39:50 GMT

    STEVENS COUNTY, Wash. - It's been nearly two years since anyone has seen or heard from Paul Brazeau. He was last seen at his son's wedding. His brokenhearted family reached out to KHQ's Hayley Guenthner with a letter asking for his case to be featured in our Q6 Cold Case series. The day Paul vanished started out so wonderful. "It was a happy day," said Paul's aunt Georgine Glatt. 

    >>

    STEVENS COUNTY, Wash. - It's been nearly two years since anyone has seen or heard from Paul Brazeau. He was last seen at his son's wedding. His brokenhearted family reached out to KHQ's Hayley Guenthner with a letter asking for his case to be featured in our Q6 Cold Case series. The day Paul vanished started out so wonderful. "It was a happy day," said Paul's aunt Georgine Glatt. 

    >>
  • Kavanaugh denies 2nd claim of sexual misconduct

    Kavanaugh denies 2nd claim of sexual misconduct

    Sunday, September 23 2018 8:44 PM EDT2018-09-24 00:44:00 GMT

    WASHINGTON (AP) - The New Yorker magazine is reporting that Senate Democrats are investigating a second woman's accusation of sexual misconduct by Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh from his teenage years. In a story posted Sunday night on its website, The New Yorker reports that the claim dates to the 1983-84 academic year, Kavanaugh's freshman year at Yale University.

    >>

    WASHINGTON (AP) - The New Yorker magazine is reporting that Senate Democrats are investigating a second woman's accusation of sexual misconduct by Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh from his teenage years. In a story posted Sunday night on its website, The New Yorker reports that the claim dates to the 1983-84 academic year, Kavanaugh's freshman year at Yale University.

    >>
  • Grant County crews fully contain five-acre fire in Ephrata

    Grant County crews fully contain five-acre fire in Ephrata

    Sunday, September 23 2018 7:22 PM EDT2018-09-23 23:22:16 GMT

    EPHRATA, Wash. - Crews in Grant County were successfully able to contain a wildfire that started in Ephrata and threatened a shop late Sunday morning. Around 11:15 a.m., Grant County Fire District 13 responded to the fire that was started by welding/grinding in the 13000 block of Rd. A.5 NW. Upon arrival, crews found a wind-driven fire threatening a shop.

    >>

    EPHRATA, Wash. - Crews in Grant County were successfully able to contain a wildfire that started in Ephrata and threatened a shop late Sunday morning. Around 11:15 a.m., Grant County Fire District 13 responded to the fire that was started by welding/grinding in the 13000 block of Rd. A.5 NW. Upon arrival, crews found a wind-driven fire threatening a shop.

    >>